Bob Galvin - The Man Who Built Motorola - Dies at 89
All CEOs should study what made Galvin a great leader
Read the full Forbes Post
Eric Jackson's Blog About Longs, Shorts, Hedge Funds, Corporate Governance, and China
All CEOs should study what made Galvin a great leader
Read the full Forbes Post
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:51 AM
View Comments
Labels: Bob Galvin, Chris Galvin, Ed Zander, MMI, MOT, Motorola, MSI, Yahoo, YHOO
Motorola's (MOT) numbers this morning weren't pretty. For once in a long time, it wasn't only the Mobile Devices division that did in the quarter but the home networks and enterprise ones joined in, with profits in those units down 25% and 37% respectively from a year earlier.
Like a lot of companies this earnings season, MOT missed on the top line but beat on the bottom.
Mobile devices will not be spun-off any time soon, according to co-CEO Sanjay Jha.
Investors didn't like what they heard, and shares are off 7% this afternoon.
The company does have a number of positive things going for it. We're likely approaching the trough for worldwide sales of mobile devices. As people shun traditional PCs in favor of lighter netbooks and mobile computing devices, this market is set to rebound. RIMM's and Apple's (AAPL) recent earnings demonstrate this thesis is working. It's also comforting to know that, as bad as things have been for MOT, it still sold more phones than RIMM and AAPL did last quarter combined.
The bad news is that MOT is still led by an awkward co-CEO structure that was created when splitting the company seemed imminent. Greg Brown was an uninspiring choice to replace Ed Zander from the start. This company's board is still pretty much the one that oversaw the company perform hari-kari on itself. It's also very quickly destroyed its brand identity it had recaptured thanks to the RAZR.
It's possible the roll-out of the Google (GOOG) Android phones later in the year will create some buzz to jumpstart flagging mobile devices sales (down 45% from a year ago), but those are quite a few eggs in one basket. I would stay away from MOT.
Position: None.
Originally published in RealMoney.com on 4/30/2009 3:11 PM EDT
To get Eric Jackson's real-time updates, subscribe to RealMoney.com
Posted by
Unknown
at
11:32 AM
View Comments
Labels: AAPL, Apple, Ed Zander, GOOG, Google, greg brown, Motorola, RAZR2, Sanjay Jha
From TheDeal.com
by Michael Rudnick
Posted 05:39 EST, 23, Jan 2009
Eric Jackson, founder of upstart activist hedge fund Ironfire Capital LLC, may be a minnow in a big pond, but he knows how to navigate the backwaters.
The voluble activist, better known as the instigator of a broad, Internet-based campaign against Yahoo! Inc. in 2007, plans to attract small investors to a new online network and serve as a catalyst for activist campaigns against selected targets.
Jackson, 36, does not plan to recruit investors for his hedge fund. Rather the Web site, to launch sometime in June, is expected to funnel campaigns against more visible, large-cap companies, he said in an interview.
Jackson, whose year-old Naples, Fla., hedge fund manages less than $5 million, hopes to replicate the successful activist campaign he waged against Yahoo!. He may lack the deep pockets of larger activists, but he has a knack for grass-roots organizing using viral communication.
The yet unnamed site will be segmented into a number of campaigns Jackson will coordinate, he said. It will include a messaging component in which investors will share views about the target companies.
Interested parties must provide information about their holdings in the targeted companies.
The site will offer several features, such as a Wiki software component enabling visitors to create and edit alternative plans for the targeted companies. It will post links to third-party video sites where investors can create visual presentations discussing the targeted companies.
The site will allow users to vote on campaign proposals, and learn the how-to's from a tutorial section.
Jackson said he will take stakes in target companies and will serve as the "spokesman" for the shareholder groups pooled through the Web site.
Eventually, he hopes to pass the torch to other individual investors.
To help finance the launch, Jackson is in talks with a potential partner, though he said he is prepared to go it alone, if necessary. A partnership with online messaging networks is also under negotiation.
Before launching Ironfire in 2008, Jackson, a Toronto native, was president at Toronto-based Jackson Leadership Systems, a management consulting firm founded by his father, David Jackson. The firm specialized in corporate governance.
Before that, he was an executive at software company VoiceGenie Technologies Inc. — which Alcatel-Lucent acquired in 2006 — while he completed a Ph.D. at Columbia University Business School. While studying corporate governance, he met with activist Ralph Whitworth of Relational Investors LLC, who has been a strong influence ever since.
In 2007, Jackson pushed for the ouster of Motorola Inc. CEO Ed Zander. Though that campaign faltered, Jackson organized 131 investors because he believed management would not ultimately give in.
He had better luck in the Yahoo! effort: He stoked up an online campaign, dashing off blogs and drawing a steady stream of comments from other Yahoo! shareholders. His nine-point plan called for the ouster of then-chairman and CEO Terry Semel, pointing to numerous strategic failures that hurt the company's share price. He also called for the ouster of six other directors, among other demands.
At Yahoo!'s annual meeting in June 2007, more than 30% of its shareholders voted against the re-election of Semel to the board, due partly to pressure Jackson created.
"Something Eric Jackson is good at is getting media focus, which can have a viral effect among investors," said Bruce Goldfarb, CEO of New York-based proxy solicitor Okapi Partners LLC.
He added that his success at Yahoo! may be due to "picking the right target at the right time."
Typically in uncontested elections, about 90% of shareholders vote for the candidate, Jackson said. He confronted Semel at the meeting with his gripes. A week later Semel stepped down, and Jerry Yang replaced him.
Jackson's backing from shareholders was relatively small, but the sentiment was widely shared. "We had good ideas that resonated with other shareholders," Jackson said.
Many of the other shareholders were big institutional investors "who are not built to be activists," he added. Nonetheless, while those institutional shareholders did not formally join his group, Yahoo!'s largest institutional shareholders told him behind the scenes that it supported his efforts.
The online campaign against Yahoo! differed from a typical activist campaign "in that it was a community of people where the best ideas rose to the top," Jackson said.
Posted by
Unknown
at
7:57 PM
View Comments
Labels: Alcatel-Lucent, Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, Ironfire Capital, Jerry Yang, Motorola, Ralph Whitworth, Relational Investors, Terry Semel, VoiceGenie, Yahoo
Cross-posted from this morning's TheStreet.com:
Motorola's (MOT - Cramer's Take - Stockpickr) fall from its perch atop the mobile-phone world has taken less than a year.
A year ago, the company successfully convinced its shareholders that they shouldn't elect Carl Icahn to the board, after the activist shareholder ran an unsuccessful proxy contest to shake things up at the company. Motorola management claimed that he was out of touch with the long-term interests of the company, as he had called on Motorola in early 2007 to initiate a massive stock-buyback plan and take on significant debt.
Management promised a turnaround was right around the corner for the 80-year-old company, with exciting new handsets beyond the Razr, and shareholders chose to believe them.
Today, Motorola's former CEO, Ed Zander, is on his way out after a string of missed quarters following last year's annual meeting. The company still has no stand-alone head of its mobile devices business (the current CEO, Greg Brown, is acting head). And the much-promised new handsets have been flops. Motorola now says the next batch of exciting new devices won't appear until well into 2009.
Instead of facing a proxy battle with Icahn again this year, Motorola recently folded its cards and agreed to appoint two of the investor's representatives to the board. The company also caved to Icahn's demand that the company split itself up in order to better recognize the value of the underlying businesses.
You might think these moves are enough to bring back the magic at Moto. They're not.
For the last 20 years, Motorola has perennially underperformed its potential. Back in the 1980s, Motorola was an American icon, a name arguably as big as General Electric's (GE - Cramer's Take - Stockpickr). Today, a comparison between the two is laughable. From 1992 through today, GE stock gains have outperformed Motorola roughly 450% vs. 50% (vs. 250% for the S&P 500).
History Repeating
What's also maddeningly frustrating for me as a shareholder is that Motorola already lived this current nightmare of its revenue dropping off a cliff 10 years ago. The company had a hot phone that grew so popular it took attention from developing other devices until -- after a great run -- the well ran dry and the company had to start from scratch. I'm not talking about the Razr -- but the StarTAC.
If you bought some Moto stock 10 years ago, you were getting in just as the StarTac was becoming the "must have" phone at the time. Attention-craving execs would lay it out on their lunch tables, eliciting compliments from others. Your Moto investment would have doubled in a couple of years.
Fashion designers know they have to change their lines every season, but Motorola's board and management team didn't. They failed to produce any popular successors, and Moto's shares lost 75% of their value from 2000 to 2003.
The board brought in Ed Zander in early 2004 to replace former CEO Chris Galvin. The ultra-slim Razr was just being released and it became the new StarTac. From the start of 2004 to October 2006, Moto's shares rose 60% -- triple the S&P's performance.
After three years of selling Razrs, with countless knock-offs, Motorola again hit the wall. Its stock is down 63% from 18 months ago. Despite its latest changes, Motorola needs to do much more.
Last July, worried that the company was going to sit back after beating back Icahn's bid for a board seat, I launched an activist campaign as an individual shareholder in Motorola. Using Web tools like blogging, YouTube videos, wikis and a "pledge your Moto shares" widget, I encouraged 130 other small investors to pledge a collective 600,000 Motorola shares (worth about $6 million today) in support of a "Plan B" of changes for the company to follow.
Unfortunately, the company failed to enact almost all of our "Plan B," except for replacing Zander.
When I launched my own activist hedge fund earlier this year, I deliberately bought no Motorola shares (although I still own some personally). Based on Motorola's inaction since I began my campaign, I couldn't look my own shareholders in the eye and justify an investment in the company.
However, I still feel a sense of loyalty to the many people who joined up with my campaign last year and want to see this company finally right itself. Many of the 130 people who "pledged" their shares with me last year were current or former Moto employees. Some of them have recently contacted me and asked my opinion on how they should vote their shares at the upcoming Motorola annual meeting on May 5. To them, I say: You have the power to finally improve this company by how you vote your shares.
A Bureaucratic Board
Motorola's board is highly dysfunctional. At 14 members, it's too large and bureaucratic. In my experience, when boards get larger than 10 members, they become more formal, there is less time for discussion and debate and the directors are more reluctant to speak up. It becomes less like a meeting of high-level advisers wanting to understand the growth of the business and protect the interests of shareholders and more like a slow day at the U.N. General Assembly.
Motorola has some very strong members (including its new Chairman David Dorman, who used to run AT&T (T - Cramer's Take - Stockpickr), and Tom Meredith, who has been acting CFO since last year and formerly Dell's (DELL - Cramer's Take - Stockpickr) CFO). And although the two new Icahn reps should help matters, this board needs an overhaul.
This group, charged with overseeing and monitoring the state of Motorola on behalf of shareholders, clearly shares the blame for what has happened. Yet, all the incumbent directors from last year (except Zander) are up for election again this year. That's simply wrong.
What's particularly puzzling is why Samuel Scott III, Judy Lewent, Nicholas Negroponte and Dr. John White are still on this board. I don't have anything against the backgrounds or experience of them, but each of these directors has been on the board for more than 10 years. That means they've had a front row seat to the two boom-and-bust cycles of the StarTac and the Razr. How could they let exactly the same problems occur twice under their watch?
Even in the best performing companies, no director (unless they're a founder or critical officer) should be on a board for a decade. Fresh eyes should be periodically cycled into the group to ensure it never becomes too clubby. For a company that's lost half its value in the last decade, it's unconscionable to have four directors with such a lengthy tenure. (Scott's actually been on the board for 15 years.)
Unless you're the owner or the owner's child, you don't get to drive out half the value in a company over 10 years and keep your job.
That's why all fellow Motorola shareholders should vote "withhold" for directors Lewent, Negroponte, Scott and John White. They should also vote "for" the three shareholder proposal on say-on-pay, recouping unearned management bonuses and new corporate standards at Motorola. In doing so, they'll embarrass the old guard into leaving.
Voting "against" directors does have an impact. I urged institutional and retail shareholders to vote against several of Yahoo!'s (YHOO - Cramer's Take - Stockpickr) directors last June (here's one of my YouTube political-style campaign ads). Thanks also to the company's poor performance, high executive compensation and support from some of the proxy advisory firms, several Yahoo! directors received over 35% "against" votes. Six days later, Terry Semel resigned as CEO.
Motorola shareholders should be upset at this company's performance. But Icahn's involvement is not a cure-all. It would be easy to be a free rider as a shareholder and think that you can leave it to Icahn to fix things. That's not enough. Many more changes need to be made at the board-level and within this company. Get out and vote.
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:54 AM
View Comments
Labels: Carl Icahn, Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, greg brown, John white, Judy Lewent, keith meister, Motorola, Nicholas Negroponte, Samuel Scott
Yesterday, Motorola announced that Dave Dorman will take over from Ed Zander as the Board's Chair. I very much support this development.
When I first spoke out for changes at Motorola last summer, I was critical of the management and the board. There are several directors whose tenure exceeds 10 years. Simply put, they've now overseen the rise and fall of StarTAC and RAZR -- with nothing learned and no consequences.
Carl Icahn getting 2 seats at the table helps, but more work needs to be done in over-hauling this board. Some of the old guard need to move on.
Dorman is a breath of fresh air for shareholders. He has relevant experience and a solid reputation.
Here's what I said about him and the rest of the board last summer:
If you had a sense of déjà vu watching what happened with RAZR, it’s because Motorola has lived the story before of riding the wave of a hot product without sufficient heed to where the industry is moving to. Ten years ago, it was with StarTAC: the “iconic” hit phone, which was analog-based. All the signs pointed to the industry moving to digital. However, Motorola’s plans for digital phones were delayed, so that additional resources could “feed the beast” of StarTAC. The company almost drove off the precipice as a result. Fortunately, for its customers, employees, and shareholders, it pulled itself back from the brink. You would hope that an organization would institutionalize the learnings of such a heralding experience. Yet, the parallels between RAZR and StarTAC are eerie. Why didn’t Motorola learn?
Chris Galvin, the former CEO and grandson of Motorola’s founder, is no longer around. However, 4 of Motorola’s current board of 11 were around. Judy Lewent, the CFO for Merck, has served on the board since 1995. Nicolas Negroponte, a director of the MIT media lab, has been on the board since 1996. Dr. John White, the Chancellor of the University of Arkansas, has been on the board since 1995. And Samuel Scott III, the head of a corn refining business, has been on the board for almost 15 years.
In the wake of Sarbanes-Oxley, a lot of attention has rightly been paid to the issue of board “independence.” It is a good thing to have directors who are sufficiently vigilant and will ask hard questions of management. Yet, how “independent” can you be when you’ve served on a board for over a decade? Meg Whitman, CEO of eBay, famously said that no CEO should stay in the same job for 10 years or they risk becoming stale in the saddle.[6] We agree and think this same benchmark should apply to all corporate directors for the sake of fresh eyes and energetic vigilance.
One argument a defender of keeping a director on the same board for over a decade could make is that: it is critical for retaining some “institutional memory” in board discussions. Presumably, these longer-serving directors could remind their shorter-tenured brethren about organizational mistakes made in the past that shouldn’t be repeated – such as StarTAC. We thank Ms. Lewent, Mr. Negroponte, Dr. White, and Mr. Scott for their service, but respectfully and strongly suggest that the company would be better served by new independent directors with strong business and communications experience....
[T]he Motorola board has – in the past – chosen to appoint directors with an abundance of experience outside Motorola’s core communications industry. While we don’t advocate a board only consisting of industry veterans, we believe a solid majority should be experienced within the markets in which Motorola directly competes, rather than – for example – from the pharmaceutical, consumer packaged goods, agricultural, and academic worlds. Therefore, we suggest replacements for the 4 people named above reflect this.
New Motorola director David Dorman who is ex-AT&T fits the bill for what we’re asking.
From IR Magazine:
Apr 02, 2008
Activists trigger company split
ILLINOIS -- After seeking a more independently led mobile division for nearly a year, activist shareholders have finally succeeded: Motorola will split off its mobile devices group.
Billionaire Carl Icahn has been demanding company reform since his proxy battle for a seat on the board was defeated last year. But Motorola’s second-largest shareholder has not been the only catalyst for the recently planned break-up.
Smaller activist investors have also pressured the company. Eric Jackson of Ironfire Capital, an activist hedge fund, has demanded change since last summer through his blog ‘Plan B for Motorola’. Its following of 600,000 pledged shares has seen some demands realized.
‘One of the Plan B criticisms was that Motorola had not hired a head for the mobile devices group, an omission the company remedied a week after the plan first came out,’ Jackson says. But Motorola’s CEO Greg Brown got rid of the new position earlier this year when he replaced Ed Zander, whose ousting was also proposed in Plan B.
Motorola has not introduced new members to the bored or outlined a long-term vision and strategy for the company, two issues dear to Plan B’s heart. But Jackson thinks it is very likely Icahn will get four seats on the board this year due to continued poor performance and decreased confidence in company management.
By Taylor Swinney
Posted by
Unknown
at
1:03 PM
View Comments
Labels: Carl Icahn, Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, greg brown, Motorola
[Posted on March 27, 2008 at 3:42 PM]
By Ron Orol
Two months after Carl Icahn failed to have his nominee elected in a proxy contest at Motorola Inc. in 2007, YouTube video blogger Eric Jackson jumped into the fray. His activism strategy used a YouTube video he dubbed "Plan B for Motorola" and an Internet Wiki to attract support from other micro-investors like himself. Like Icahn, Jackson wanted Motorola CEO Ed Zander gone, much of the board replaced and a new head of Mobile Devices with a clear strategy.
When the company revealed major financial problems in its second quarter 2007 financials two days later, Jackson says his effort began receiving major support. He got the backing of roughly 150 investors with about $600,000 in shares, less than 1% but significant nonetheless.
"They didn't move quickly enough, so starting late last year, we started saying that the best course of action, given the extent of the problems in the company, was to break it up," Jackson says.
And while Icahn's two-year public prodding is certainly the major reason why Motorola decided Wednesday it will split into two independent, publicly traded companies, Jackson's novel approach to activism is lifting eyebrows. Anne Faulk, chief executive of Swingvote Inc. in Atlanta, says Jackson may be the vanguard of how shareholders and executives communicate with each other. Certainly, some of Jackson's goals -- having Motorola executive Ed Zander resign and seeing that the company divide into two units -- have been accomplished.
The same can be said of Jackson's efforts last year at his first YouTube activist campaign at Yahoo! Inc., which also has gone through serious changes since his insurgency began. Jackson sent out a "Yahoo! Plan B" YouTube video and later launched a "just vote no" campaign to persuade shareholders of the widely used Santa Clara, Calif.-based portal to expel its CEO, Terry Semel, from his chairmanship along with six others on the company's 10-person board. He also set up a blog, "Breakout Performance," a MySpace.com account and a LinkedIn Web site to spread dissent.
Semel later did resign, and now Microsoft Corp. has a $31 a share, or $44.6 billion offer on the table.
With the stock of Motorola still low at around $10 a share, don't expect Jackson to end his insurgency just yet. In February Jackson launched a $2 million activist fund, Ironfire Capital LLC. Even with few dollars behind him, corporations should beware of Jackson's YouTube "Plan B." - Ron Orol
See Breakout Performance
See Jackson's YouTube page
See the Motorola Wiki
Posted by
Unknown
at
9:51 PM
View Comments
Labels: Carl Icahn, Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, Motorola, Terry Semel, Yahoo
Following the launching of our "Plan B" campaign for Motorola on July 9th, we called on the company to enact several actions to restore this company to its rightful spot of industry leadership. One of our suggested changes was replacing Ed Zander as CEO.
I have nothing against Zander. I know people who speak well of him and his time at Sun. I'm sure the last year has been tough on him and his family. However, it's a good thing for Motorola that he is leaving as CEO. Following many interactions with Motorola employees over the last 4.5 months, it's clear that they had lost faith in him.
Unfortunately, most I've spoken to have lost faith in most of the SLT -- perhaps save for Tom Meredith in Finance and also Legal (for what that's worth). Greg Brown, incoming CEO, is not well-liked.
I was concerned when he was appointed to the Board in August -- another insider added to a board with too many people and long-standing members already. Now, it's clear that the board had already decided back in the summer that Zander was not the man for the job. They were lining up Brown, while continuing to give him a few months more of seasoning.
Motorola has tried hard in the last few days to portray Brown as ready for the job. Several investors have said he's not the right person for the job... he doesn't have the "cachet" that some possible outsiders would.
I always advise clients that insiders statistically have a greater likelihood of success than outsiders. Therefore, if you've got a qualified insider -- more often than not -- you're better off with that person.
I don't think that fits here though. Although we'll have to see how Brown responds in the next 60 days, I don't believe he's the right person for the job for the following reasons:
1. Most people inside the company with whom I've interacted are not too fond of him. If he's their leader, they're not ready yet to follow.
2. Although he has a relevant background working at AT&T and Ameritech in the past, his resume seems lacking for this job. Micromuse was a small company, relative to Motorola. CEO experience at a much smaller company doesn't count as relevant CEO experience for this position. Senior leadership at a much bigger company would have been more comforting to shareholders.
3. Brown is as responsible for the current state of Motorola as Zander or anyone else. He's been on the earnings calls for at least the last year, doing his best to show Wall Street that he "gets" the need for urgency. He's used tough talk cliches ("no excuses") -- moreso than Zander and Meredith -- since they first missed at the start of the year, but performance has only gotten worse, not better. His elevation is a likely sign that Q4 is not going well. Check back on that in the 3rd week of January when they report results.
4. At least someone, somewhere tried to draw a comparison between Brown and Mark Hurd. The point was: both aren't flashy, so Brown should be able to replicate Hurd's results at Motorola as a result. Hurd under-promises and over-delivers. Brown has, so far this year, over-promised and under-delivered. Also, Hurd took a $2 billion company in NCR when he took over as CEO in March 2003 and grew it to $6 billion. Micromuse was much smaller when Brown was CEO. Micromuse was a different animal than Motorola. Despite the fact that Brown's been there for a few years now, he'll be learning on the job as CEO for a while.
Given all this, I agree with Carl Icahn that Motorola needs to be broken up now. With Brown in charge, and with the current board, Motorola shareholders would be much better off getting some value from the parts of Motorola, rather than keeping with the whole. Brown can endear himself to all Motorola investors by proactively taking this issue on now -- rather than being forced into this position if he waits another year and the stock slides below $10.
Finally, let the record show that Motorola would have been better off as a company if shareholders had elected Icahn to the board back in May. Shareholders were promised by Zander and Brown a turnaround once new handset models hit the market at the end of June; that didn't happen. Shareholders were promised by Zander and Brown a return to profitability before the end of the year; that won't happen. If Icahn had been sitting around the board table for the last 6 months -- holding directors' and management's feet to the fire -- shareholders would have been better off.
Let's hope Brown aggressively takes action to start to benefit Motorola shareholders. That would differentiate himself from his predecessor.
From the Nov. 30/07 Daily Herald:
Says transition was in the works for a while
By Anna Marie Kukec Daily Herald Staff
Ed Zander's resignation today as chief executive of beleaguered Motorola Inc. didn't surprise Wall Street. Indeed, he said he has been planning this transition for the last two years by grooming his successor, Chief Operating Officer Greg Brown.
"It's time," said Zander, during an interview. "When I got here, it was a big move for me coming from the West Coast more than four years ago. My wife and I did a lot of soul searching and I was in a place in my career that I wanted to just take a chance here in Chicago."
Zander, 60, said he started talking with the board two years ago about putting a succession plan into place. That was when Motorola's share price was in the $20 range, the highest he would see during his tenure. Zander then put Brown, now 47, on the fast track by promoting him to different leadership positions.
"We kept giving Greg every conceivable job that we could throw at him and asked him to help build up this enterprise," Zander said. "And he's done a great job."
Brown will replace Zander by Jan. 1 while Zander will continue as chairman of the board. Zander doesn't receive any severance package because he resigned. But he still is eligible for all stock options and restricted stocks that vest Jan. 5, 2009, which would have been his retirement date.
In addition, Zander will be an adviser to Brown until Jan. 5, 2009, and so will be paid his regular salary and benefits until then, Motorola spokesman Chuck Kaiser said.
Zander's total compensation package earlier this year was estimated around $13 million.
Despite the take-home pay, it's been a long haul for the West Coast tech veteran of 40 years, whose career includes stints as managing director of private equity fund Silver Lake Partners and president and chief operating officer of Sun Microsystems.
By February 2004, Zander shivered through his first winter in Chicago and skied in with Wall Street accolades on the coat-tails of the then new Razr phone. That world-changing handset was under production by former Motorola CEO and grandson of a co-founder Christopher Galvin, who retired under pressure.
Coincidentally, Motorola's share price when Zander took over was $18.45 with an adjusted close of $15.95 in February 2004. The price peaked in the $20-range from mid-2005 through late 2006. The stock closed up 32 cents to $15.97 today.
"Ed Zander's big mistake was thinking that the single success of the Razr phone was enough. It was not," said independent telecom analyst Jeff Kagan of Atlanta, Ga. "The Razr may have been hot, but Motorola needed to replace it with another hot phone. Instead they rode it up and rode it back down again."
During his tenure, Zander faced much of what Galvin faced: the No. 2-rated mobile phone maker began a downward spiral in global market share against stiff competition, profits dwindled, layoffs and closed plants continued.
This year, especially, was hard on Zander and the company when billionaire activist Carl Icahn sought in vain to win a seat on the board.
"I like Ed Zander personally; I never thought that he was the right man for the job at Motorola," Icahn said in a statement today. "Further, I believe that the steps announced today do not even begin to address the major problems at Motorola. In my opinion, Motorola should be split into separate companies: a mobile devices company; an enterprise mobility company; a connected home company; and a company focused on mobile networks infrastructure."
A Florida-based consultant began a campaign to unseat Zander just as he did to Yahoo's CEO Terry Semel.
"I'm ecstatic. It's a step in the right direction, but it's not the entire solution," said Eric Jackson, president of Jackson Leadership Systems Inc., a governance consulting firm in Naples, Fla. He offered the Motorola board a reorganization plan that called for Zander to leave.
"This was needed," Jackson said. "You can't change much without starting with the top.
While Zander is removing himself from day-to-day operations, he will continue to be active on the board.
"That's a way of saving face," Jackson said. "It's more of a symbolic role. Eighteen months from now, he may not be chairman anymore."
Zander said in the last six months or so, he was working more closely with Brown to make the transition. In July, Brown and Chief Financial Officer Thomas Meredith insisted during an interview with the Daily Herald that Zander would remain at the helm despite Wall Street rumors a successor was being sought.
"Ed and I have been working very closely, especially these last few months," Brown said during an interview today. "We have been focusing on reconfiguring this company and integrating a lot of talent. This is a special company and it still has great potential."
Brown said together they've changed about 50 percent of the leaders in the mobile devices business.
Said Jane Zweig, a wireless devices analyst with The Shosteck Group in Columbia, Md.: "Brown is an organization guy, a networks guy, but he's not a consumer electronics guy."
"You still need someone in there with a good strong background in devices. Stu Reed, who heads up the supply chair, would be possible," Zweig said. "But this still raises the question of what Motorola has coming down the pipeline. Will it turn people's heads like the Razr once did?"
There is no magic turn-around key for Motorola, so Brown has his work cut out for him, said Mark McKechnie, an analyst with American Technology Research.
"The good news is, Motorola is promoting from within again, which can provide some consistency," McKechnie said. "It's better than when they brought in Zander from the outside, which didn't work."
Despite the detractors, Zander has many friends in the industry, including Stephen Luczo, who knew Zander when he was at Seagate Technology in Scotts Valley, Calif., where Zander had served on the board.
"We're happy that Ed's coming home," said Luczo. "He's done a good job at Motorola and Brown is also an outstanding guy. It's a testament to Zander to be able to do such a smooth transition."
Interviews with the press are often illuminating. Despite the best efforts of corporate PR folks, not every comment can be scripted. Eventually, all of us have to stand on our own feet and speak -- warts and all.
I received my monthly Portfolio issue last night and was disturbed (as a Motorola shareholder) by some of the comments contained within an interview the magazine's Kevin Maney did with Motorola CEO Ed Zander.
Ed Zander has had previous off-the-cuff remarks come back to haunt him before. Earlier this year, leading up to the May Annual Meeting, at which Carl Icahn fought for a board seat, a Wall Street Journal article quoted Zander as having previously said in an internal meeting that he loved his job but hated his customers. Icahn later called the remark something "straight out of 'Alice in Wonderland.'"
Fortunately for Zander, there's no damning comment like that in this latest interview. However, there are several odd remarks which are worth noting. Ladies and gentlemen of the Motorola shareholder jury, these comments speak to the defendent's state of mind at the time he was (and still is to this day) running Motorola.
The video interview is here. The full printed interview is here. Excerpts are below with my comments.
CondeNastPortfolio: What went wrong for Motorola this year?
Zander: There was a disruptive technology called 3G. We underestimated when it would hit—thought we had another year—and we were late rolling out our products that use it. But in this business, you have to get the devices out across the world and in all price points. That's what were doing right now.
[Jackson: Underestimating 3G harkens back to Motorola's being late to digital from analog back in the 90s. Interestingly, 3 current Motorola directors were on Motorla's board then too. One of the arguments for keeping a director on the board longer than a decade would have to be that their institutional memory gives a valuable perspective to the board so that "newbie" directors and management don't make similar mistakes to the past. It would have been nice for Motorola shareholders if that had happened here.]
CNP: The stock price falls, and you have one of those classic nightmare moments: Your assistant walks into your office and says, "Carl Icahn's on line 1."
ZANDER: [Smiles] He wasn't on line 1. He was on my cell phone.
CNP: What did you talk about?
ZANDER: I don't want to go into that. I'll just say that last December we realized the products we had weren't what customers wanted, so we had to cut prices. And that was a big hole in our January earnings announcement. At the end of the month, I got a phone call from Mr. Icahn. It was surreal.
CNP: What did he say?
ZANDER: Keep in mind, at that time I had a great balance sheet. When I got to Motorola in 2004, we had so much debt that we had a hard time making our payments. So we worked real hard to get a really strong balance sheet. Icahn's team felt that money should be redistributed to the shareholders in order to get the stock up again. We didn't think so. And we had a lot of pleasant meetings.
[Jackson: "I had a great balance sheet"? The use of the word "I" is very interesting. In a company with as many employees (and executives on the Senior Leadership Team), no "I" does anything. It's concerning that he would see things in this way.]
CNP: Speaking of that, when you came in at Motorola, you went around visiting customers and got slammed.
ZANDER: That's a nice word for it. They pounded me for Motorola's poor quality, missed deliveries, whatever. So we made customer satisfaction part of our executive team's bonuses.
[Jackson: Translation... This company was a basket-case before I arrived. I had to fix these sorry guys up.]
CNP: At the Consumer Electronics Show, in January, you showed me a little card stating Motorola's corporate values and mentioned a big internal fight over the wording.
ZANDER: The line we fought over is "We're here to win." In Silicon Valley—I don't care if you're in last place—you think about winning every day. That line was too aggressive for some people at Motorola, but we're now No. 1 in set-top boxes for cable TV. We're No. 1 in government and public-safety radio communications.
[Jackson: The reference to the good old days back in "Silicon Valley" won't win many fans in Schaumberg or Naperville.]
CNP: What's the next Razr?
ZANDER: The Razr was like hitting a grand slam, and you can't hit a grand slam every time. You win baseball games with lots of singles and doubles, good fielding, good pitching. In the global device business, if you want to be successful, you have to be maniacally boring.
CNP: What do you mean?
ZANDER: It's about having lots of products come out on time. It's the supply chain. It's the cost structure.
[Jackson: 100% agree with everything Zander said in the last 2 comments. However, he and the rest of the SLT (including Meredith and Reed) use the term "maniacal" and "drumbeat" and "wave upon wave" way too much. We get it. However, this answer to "what's the next RAZR question has changed from 2006. Here's what the Wall Street Journal reported earlier this year: "A lot of you are always asking what is after the Razr," Mr. Zander said in an April 2006 conference call after another quarter of 30%-plus growth. "I say more Razrs."]
CNP: You've taken some hits recently for not buying Navteq. It's in your backyard; former Motorola C.E.O. Chris Galvin is the chairman...
ZANDER: I didn't know that about Chris Galvin.
[Jackson: Seriously? If not, why not? If you did, why would you say you didn't?]
CNP: He didn't call you up and say, "Ed, you should buy this company"?
ZANDER: No. But even if he had, Navteq has nothing to do with us. We're not in the applications business. You've got to pick what side you want to be on. Our goal is to provide the best platform for developers to create applications.
[Jackson: It's too bad Galvin didn't - could have been good for MOT and Navteq. As I've said elsewhere, I respectfully believe that Motorola desperately needs to be in the applications (some might call it services) business. If they don't, others -- like Google -- will take that piece of the value chain and Motorola will relegate itself to being a plastic shell hardware provider. The iPhone is apps plus form factor; it's not just a touch-screen. Nokia believes they needs to be in the apps business. Motorola thinks they'll win over services providers (phone companies) by not competing against them like some perceive Nokia to be doing. At the end of the day, the most valuable aspect of this value chain is in apps and Motorola has the special and unique advantage (over a Google) to combine form factor with apps.]
CNP: The price for Navteq was stunning: Nokia paid more than $8 billion.
ZANDER: God bless them, but that's just crazy.
[Jackson: We'll see. Anyway, it's a moot point, as Motorola couldn't have afforded to outbid for this. Therefore, blame your competitor for paying too much foolishly (see Google after the Microsoft investment in Facebook).]
CNP: Do you wish Motorola had the iPhone?
ZANDER: I have nothing but respect for Apple, but we did touchscreens with handwriting recognition in China three years ago. We, as an industry, tried touchscreens in the U.S. several years ago, and it didn't work. A lot of Americans don't like them.
[Jackson: If you believe the iPhone is just about having a touchscreen, I have a problem with that. Again, we'll see on the prediction. I would say the early returns don't support his view.]
CNP: What device do you use?
ZANDER: A Moto Q when I'm working. When I go out at night, I may have a Razr2. Eventually, you'll have one SIM card for your mobile devices, and when you plug that card in, it will recognize the device and shut off all your other devices. I think many of our customers will buy multiple devices, depending on the applications they want, and they'll have one phone number that works for all of them.
[Jackson: With the exception of some of my engineering friends, I don't see mass popping of SIM cards into and out of mutliple devices on a large-scale in the near future.]
CNP: Or so you hope.
ZANDER: Yeah.
[Jackson: Yeah. Motorola shareholders hope so too.]
It's been a rough-go for Motorola in the last few weeks. After its last quarterly call in which it guided higher for the Fourth Quarter, the market has treated it harsher than the general market during the month of November. The stock has slipped. Some critics are suggesting it be dumped outright -- frustrated because of a lack of change in management. We don't think so - yet. This is a company which can still save itself -- although there's no quick fix here.
Our group has been pushing Motorola's board and management for changes since July. Earlier this month, we had the opportunity to speak for over an hour with Motorola's head of IR, Dean Lindroth. Mr. Lindroth and the Management team deserve credit for listening and engaging in dialogue with a group of investors (133 individuals owning 600,000 MOT shares) who are frustrated and want to share ideas for turning around this great company.
We certainly didn't agree on each point that we presented, but they deserve respect for listening. We intend to continue to speak out in a positive and constructive fashion on ideas for how this company can better unlock value.
Here is a summary of the views we shared with Motorola:
We believe, as I’m sure management and the board do, that Motorola belongs back in its industry leadership position.
Here are our suggestions on “opportunity areas” that – if you were to implement – we believe would be received warmly by the Street and by existing Motorola shareholders and employees.
1. Improving the Culture. Any time you do RIFs, there’s obviously going to be a blow to internal morale and fingers pointed at management. From the comments I’ve heard from Ed, Tom, and Greg on this, I think your opinion is that this will work itself out as the company’s financial results improve. While I agree this will help, there’s an opportunity here to further bolster the morale: Bob Galvin. I have been impressed with how highly Bob is still regarded by Motorola employees. There is still a deep appreciation for the values he instilled in the company. Although whenever a new leader comes in, there is a need for change, there is an enormous opportunity to remind people that the best aspects of Motorola’s old culture still exist. I am not saying Ed and the team need to recapture the Motorola of old. There were some parts of that (some would say) more paternalistic culture that don’t necessarily fit in today’s marketplace. However, there were some amazing and unique aspects of the old culture which employees should be reminded about. If Ed were to meet with Bob and perhaps invite Bob to an internal “town hall” type of meeting, I think there would be a great boost to the morale. This wouldn’t diminish Ed’s status as the leader, but strengthen it.
2. Further Clarify Strategy (Business, Corporate, Software, Acquisitions). “Seamless Mobility” is a catchy phrase. I think I understand what Motorola means by it and how it results in your core three businesses, etc. However, I’m not sure and I don’t think I’m alone here. It would be helpful for me – as a shareholder – and, I believe, to other analysts, institutional investors, and employees, if Ed could more clearly spell out what Motorola is building towards in the coming 3 – 5 years. How are you going to be unique compared to Nokia, Samsung, the iPhone, and Google? How do the three businesses all fit together? What are the criteria you use for new acquisitions? How will you win in software (see point below)? You don’t want to share your most intimate of strategic details with your competitors, but – in my opinion – you’ve been too private. By not speaking up more, there is a perception created that there is not a clear strategy being followed. That was ok when things were going well with RAZR, but you can’t skate by without more explanation these days. Another way of putting this is that you could win over so many more supporters with just more explanation as to where things are heading. Tom has done a great job of this within his area. He’s provided some clear metrics to measure his effectiveness on in 1 – 2 years from now. The Street loves this. We need the equivalent of this from the strategic perspective.
3. Winning in Software/Services. I think the most important hire you’ve made in the last 6 months is not Stu Reed to lead MDB but Alain Mutricy to head up software. Many of your competitors (most notably Nokia) have staked out software/services as a key area for battle in the next 5 years. Now Apple and Google are raising the stakes further. Motorola has always known the importance of software; hence the Good acquisition. However, there is still much work to do here. Streamlining onto fewer platforms and getting Linux/Java out the door is necessary but not sufficient for beating your rivals. The bar has really been raised by the companies mentioned above (even though I know Google is technically a MOT partner, just as Windows Mobile is a partner). We need a much stronger story to tell about what’s unique and exciting from a user-perspective about Motorola’s software. Otherwise, you’re a hardware vendor. Ed knows better than anyone that that’s not a market space you want to be relegated to. You need to say more than “stay tuned” on this issue. The Street wants to know how we’ll be different.
4. Further Strengthening the Board. I know Motorola and its directors take corporate governance issues very seriously. You have some very strong individuals on the board. However, we believe that – after a certain period of time on the board – one’s independence diminishes through no fault of a director’s own. Right now, the board at Countrywide is under-fire on this issue of director tenure length.[1] A decade is a fair length of time for any non-executive director serving on any company. We appreciate the years of service provided by Judy, Lewent, Nicolas Negroponte, Samuel Scott III, and Dr. John White, but we believe there is an opportunity to bring in some fresh eyes – as you have done recently with Anthony Vinciquerra of Fox and David Dorman. We think doing so would strengthen your standing on Wall Street (assuming you pick the right people). As with the point on Culture above, there’s an opportunity here for the Company to turn a perceived weakness into a strength. Instituting a required stock purchase amount by directors would also be appreciated by the Street and – according to research I’ve done – also result in even more meaningful participation by all Motorola directors.
[1] http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119404440821681023.html
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:11 AM
0
comments
Labels: Ed Zander, Google, greg brown, Motorola, Nokia, Samsung, Tom Meredith
From yesterday's MSN Money:
Like the song says, "some say love it is a Razr that leaves your soul to bleed." Well my soul has bleed out waiting for Motorola's stock to turn around. I can't wait any longer -- I'm not Job after all.
Motorola has been screwing up for so long, it even gets it wrong when it gets it right. Last quarter the company delivered another lousy set of sales and earnings numbers, yet it guided fiscal fourth-quarter earnings to a range of 13 to 14 cents a share -- a few pennies above The Street's consensus. Normally, guiding estimates higher would be perceived as a good thing -- and it was at first as the stock edged higher on the news. However, in offering up hope for the fourth quarter and the upcoming year, CEO Ed Zander might have won himself a new contract -- and that's bad news.
You see one of the reasons I bought Motorola's stock down at its lows was in anticipation of a new management team. Typically when a struggling company finally ousts its old CEO in favor of someone new and full of promise, the underlying stock tends to rally. Until recently, Zander's ouster was all but certain. But in light of the company's modest progress off a terrible set of numbers, Zander might just hang around. Let's face it he did take all the credit for the Razr so there might be a board member or two who thinks he's on the verge of another one-hit wonder.
Now I don't know if the new CEO would be Motorola's own Greg Brown (current President and COO) or an outsider like former Qwest CEO Dick Notebaert and frankly I don't much care -- it's just at the point where anyone but Zander will do. Isn't there a young Galvin kid somewhere looking to reestablish the family name?
Without a change at the top, Motorola's stock will be stuck at the bottom. It was the one big catalyst we needed for the stock to make a run back into the low $20s. The Razr2 sure as heck isn't the answer to our turnaround prayers. Granted sales have been a little better than expected, but the price is still too high, the functionality is hit -or-miss and the design has lost its cool factor. And don't even get me started on the Q. Motorola's answer to the smart phone craze was put to shame by Apple's iPhone and Research-in-Motion's BlackBerry Pearl. Motorola can't give the phone away -- though it has tried hard, which helps to explain the company's declining margins.
So after waiting and waiting, I wait no more. Goodbye Moto.
By Anna Marie Kukec Daily Herald Staff
Published: 10/26/2007 12:14 AM
While the mobile phone business dragged down Motorola and it considers some changes between its Chicago and Libertyville operations, Chief Executive Ed Zander says he won't give up.
That upbeat attitude apparently paid off Thursday when, despite Motorola reporting a 94 percent drop in profit over the last quarter, its shares rose 75 cents, or 4 percent, to $19.30 in New York Stock Exchange composite trading, the largest gain since January.
"They're in between product cycles now and they're in a rebuilding mode, sort of like the Chicago Bears," said Mark McKechnie, an analyst with American Technology Research. "The real question down the road is how much earning power can they unlock? They have a long road to go."
Motorola's overall third-quarter profit slowed to $60 million, or 3 cents a share, compared to $968 million, or 39 cents a share, in the same quarter last year. Sales were $8.8 billion, compared to $10.6 billion the year before.
Still, while the mobile device business sales plunged 36 percent, the other businesses showed progress. Home & Networks Mobility was up 6 percent and Enterprise Mobility Solutions showed a 47 percent boost.
The company outlook for the fourth quarter said earnings per share from continuing operations would be 12 cents to 14 cents.
"We've made some progress toward stability," Zander said in an interview. "We did what we said we were going to do and actually the numbers in some areas."
So while the mobile devices unit hasn't had a hit cell phone in roughly three years after the Razr debuted, Zander said he aims to grow the company as in years past.
"After all, 49 percent of our company did very well," Zander said. "It's all about execution. We know that and we'll do that."
Zander said his top lieutenants are carrying out a turn-around strategy put in place earlier this year. This included cost-cutting and streamlining globally and the elimination of 7,500 jobs.
"Our work force plans are now complete," Motorola Chief Operating Officer Greg Brown said in an interview. "We're now focused on profitability. We know there's more work to be done."
Zander said he is eyeing more options with his downtown Chicago development center, which just expanded to a second floor.
"We'll continue to enrich Chicago and look at Libertyville and see what makes the best sense down the road," Zander said.
Libertyville is Motorola's base for its mobile devices business, which includes the development of cell phones.
Zander acknowledged this has been "an exceptionally tough year."
"We've seen some growth in other areas and we'll see more gains as we go along. We will continue to execute," Zander said. He praised his employees for undergoing a tremendous amount of pressure to produce winning products while maintaining large spending cuts.
Despite the heat this year, including power struggles with billionaire activist Carl Icahn and financial blogger Eric Jackson in bids to remove Zander, the chief executive plans to move the company ahead.
"It is looking like Zander congealed his support from the board and shareholders at least for the near term," said David Weissman, senior telecom analyst with Zacks Investment Research. "The recent shareholder letters and defeat of Carl Icahn's director initiative leads us to believe
Zander may have more time at the helm."
Zander said he likes where the company is heading.
"I like where we're at and how our engineering is being deployed," Zander said. "We're going to focus our marketing on where the opportunities are, including here in the U.S. There are plenty of opportunities here, too."
Back in January, I began a campaign against Yahoo!'s current management team and board. I was unhappy with the current direction of the company under then-CEO Terry Semel. With the help of input from many Yahoo! investors, we finalized a "Plan B" for the company, which was sent to General Counsel, Mike Callahan, in February. We met with the company in April, ran an "against" vote campaign directed at 7 of 10 directors leading up to the annual meeting in June (at which we spoke out against more aggressive changes at the company), and have continued to communicate our points to management.
Here is a quick update of the points in the plan and what has happened over the last 9 months. We are not "claiming credit" for these changes. The press has well-documented our involvement on behalf of shareholders earlier in the year. We are simply updating supporters on what we asked for and what has happened since (and we are not including our original arguments supporting each point, but refer here if interested):
1.Terry Semel should be immediately replaced as Yahoo!’s Chairman and CEO
2. Terry Semel, Robert Kotick, Roy Bostock, Ron Burkle, Eric Hippeau, Arthur Kern and Gary Wilson should be immediately replaced on Yahoo!’s Board of Directors
3. Shutter the (original content aspects of) Yahoo! Media Group and campus in Los Angeles
4. Make additional R&D Investments in the Technology Group
5. Reduce overlapping internal divisions within the Company
6. Institute a “pay-for-performance” plan for all Yahoo! Management
7. Step up the pace of the $3 billion stock repurchase plan announced in October 2006
8. Begin a modest cash dividend immediately
9. Remove anti-takeover provisions which are not shareholder-friendly
2. Replace Judy Lewent, Nicolas Negroponte, Samuel Scott III, and Dr. John White on the Motorola Board of Directors
3. Appoint Edward Lampert to the Motorola Board and others with Deep Communications Experience
4.Reduce the Size of and Insiders on the Board
5. Outline Motorola’s Strategy and How You Will Add Exciting New Products
6. Appoint a Permanent Head of the Mobile Devices Business
7.Give Motorola’s Culture an Inspirational Transfusion
On Friday, they announced the sale of their embedded computing group to Emerson for about half of its revenues from last year. It was a continued focusing of the company on its Mobile Devices Business.
Today, Nokia went to Motorola's backyard to make its largest acquisition ever of Navtaq, where, with delicious irony, Ed Zander's predecessor - Chris Galvin -- is now Chair after leaving Schaumburg. Since Galvin joined the Navteq board on Oct. 22, 2004 through today, Navteq has returned 101% to its shareholders, while Motorola has returned 1.89%. Navteq's $8.1 billion valuation is now one-fifth of Motorola's -- not bad for a company which did less than $400 million in revenues in 2004.
The Navteq deal underscores how Nokia is consciously choosing to believe industry supremacy will be fought in the future in (high-margin) software and services. Until recently, Motorola didn't have a lead software architect for the company - so, clearly, it's playing catch-up in this arena.
Stu Reed was unimpressive in his debut at last month's Financial Analysts' Meeting in New York, promising fixes to problems created under the watchful eye of CEO, Ed Zander, and COO, Greg Brown (as well as the board, of course) without any details on how.
So, the bottom line is that Motorola hasn't yet taken the steps within its control to best position the company for future growth and to ensure it will not repeat the mistakes of the past. Put another way, there is still lots of opportunity to turn this company around. But it will need to make some tough decisions -- not just cut R&D spending, cut jobs and wait for an industry rebound to pick it back up, which -- along with "Seamless Mobility" -- appears to be the strategy.
In a few weeks (although the date hasn't been released by the company yet), we'll see how things are going for Motorola in its turnaround when it discusses its Q3.
We will be watching and continue to hope this board will be open to listening to thoughts and views from its shareholders. Onwards, "Plan B."
Sphere: Related Content
Posted by
Unknown
at
2:18 PM
0
comments
Labels: Ed Zander, Jerry Yang, Motorola, Plan B, Shareholder Activism, sue decker, Terry Semel, Yahoo
From yesterday's BloggingStocks:
Renewed and unconfirmed chatter is circulating that Motorola Chairman and CEO Edward Zander may step down. RBC Capital Markets says "We're upgrading MOT to Outperform based on our view MOT is displaying firming trends in its once beleaguered handset division." RBC Capital Markets has a $21 price target on MOT. MOT call option volume of 27,010 contracts compares to put volume of 8,124 contracts. MOT October option implied volatility of 30 was near its 26-week average of 29 according to Track Data, suggesting non-directional risk.Daily options Update is provided by Stock Specialist Paul Foster of theflyonthewall.com.
The Motorola Financial Analyst Meeting held last Friday in New York lasted 4.5 hours. Most of the comments from management offered few new details of what's to come in the months ahead. It was a lot of "we'll try harder" and "stay tuned." Most of the questions from analysts during the Q&A session afterwards were polite and very granular.
I thought the best question was the last one from Michael Regan, the analyst from Janus Capital:
"What's changed now versus what you told us 2 years ago?"
It really cut through all the painstaking (over-)explanations we heard. The Motorola Senior Leadership Team went to great lengths to say how things are really different now. More people within the company understand Days Sales Outstanding. Employees' attitudes are different. Therefore, results are going to be different. Greg Brown, the COO and new Director, also answered that Motorola's leadership had changed between now and two years ago. Well, in part it has, but Brown, CEO, Ed Zander, and CFO, Tom Meredith were all there before of course -- as was Stu Reed, the new head of Mobile Devices (in a different role).
Still, the big problem facing Motorola (and it was even more evident after the meeting on Friday) is what hasn't changed, rather than what has.
CEO Zander only spoke for a half hour on Friday -- less than half the time he allocated for his generals running the 3 company divisions. His introductory remarks and later answers in the Q&A tended to ramble and state the obvious (e.g., "We have to just have flawless execution"). They conveyed the troubling sense that the division heads had a better sense of the businesses than him.
Our "Plan B" Group for Motorola has criticized Zander previously for his over-simplifing or not articulating the company's strategy, as well as heavily using pet phrases like "Seamless Mobility" (he tried to clarify this phrase on Friday by saying "some of you might prefer to call it 'Broadband Internet'" - but that wasn't really that helpful). There was nothing in his Friday comments to dissaude us from the view that he is not comfortable sharing strategy. At one point, he stated that "profitable marketshare is our strategy."
This is a perfect illustration of Zander's biggest flaw as CEO -- and a key reason for why Motorola is undergoing its current pains. Zander is a short-term, tactical thinker. He responds instinctually, likes to joke (he introduced Reed to the analysts by imploring them to "take it easy on him") and schmooze. He appears to delegate the details of setting plans and executing them to his staff -- without necessarily a firm grasp on what is happening. When he arrived at Motorola and found a hot product with RAZR, he lurched to run with it. He trumpeted and supported growing market share. Now that the company has been humbled in the last year with low sales, he is promoting the pursuit of profits. Lurching is not leading.
As an investor, I was looking for a sense of vision and precisely how this company will win. Instead, we heard a lot of market segmentation and power of positive thinking.
Most focus during the morning meeting centered on new head of Mobile Devices, Stu Reed. It was an uneventful debut. After his hour-long careful discourse, investors were assaulted with "wave after wave" of repetitions of his theme that this was a company that had learned from its mistakes. It was a monotonous "drumbeat" of a speech, with an undeniable "cadence," describing how MDB would never again follow the siren song of a "one hit wonder."
Reed went out of his way to criticize the division's past leadership. Before Reed, according to him, Motorola's Mobile Business had the "audacity" to believe it knew what the customers wanted; now, it knows better to ask them. They are going to spend internally much better now ("We are done with the years of 'double spend,'" he said at one point -- referring to spending on the same features in different parts of the company.) They're also going to be more profitable by no longer "riding a hot horse for too long." Presumably, all these are shots at Ron Garriques - the former head of MDB. Yet, from February until his July appointment (according to the Q2 earnings call), MDB was co-headed by Zander, Brown, and Meredith (supported by Ray Roman and Terry Vega). By taking shots at Garriques, Reed was indirectly pointing the finger back at his CEO, COO, and CFO. "What's changed now versus what you told us 2 years ago?"
There were several positives from Friday's meeting. Multi-sourcing silicon, having a software strategy, and the draw downs of inventory are all positive for Mobile Devices. Tom Meredith does have a good grasp for this business and the focus he's brought to it with cash conversion is encouraging.
However, Friday's Analyst meeting was heavy on dissecting the "profit pools" (meaning the market segments) Motorola will compete in, commiting to assiduous R&D spending, and pledging to keep a clamp on costs. How will they raise revenues though and be successful in their markets? Wait and see.
In our opinion, changes at the top and at the board-level are still sorely needed for this company to more quickly move ahead. To really demonstrate to the Street and all investors that things have changed this time, Motorola needs to change its top leadership -- not in wholesale fashion, but certainly at the top. A new leader -- wisely chosen -- would truly bring new life and energy to this company to build on the early signs of progress.
HP didn't have to clean house when it shifted out Carly Fiorina and introduced Mark Hurd as CEO. I suspect the same thing would happen here. What Mark Hurd has clearly demonstrated is that a new CEO -- with the right focus, strategic vision, and operational discipline -- can take a company written off for dead and bring it back to the top of an industry. It can happen again here at Motorola, but not with Ed Zander. It's time for change.
Posted by
Unknown
at
12:22 AM
2
comments
Labels: Ed Zander, Financial Analysts, greg brown, Motorola, Tom Meredith
Tomorrow, on Friday, September 7th, Motorola CEO Ed Zander and CFO Tom Meredith will hold court in New York for a Financial Analysts meeting.
Unfortunately, I will be in Orlando on business and cannot attend the meeting in person. However, I wanted to submit my question in advance via YouTube. I believe all Fortune 500 CEOs should allows for YouTube questions from shareholders at these kinds of events in the future. If our future President has to answer his/her constituents before election via this medium, why shouldn't our CEOs in which we own a share of stock?
I am a Motorola shareholder who owns 180 shares in the company. I also represent -- through the "Plan B" group I have started -- 130 additional shareholders in the company. Together, we own 600,000 Motorola shares. We are upset with the recent performance of the company.
Although we have created and formally sent Motorola's non-executive directors a "Plan B" for how to turn around Motorola and asked for a face-to-face meeting to discuss the merits of our plan, the board has refused such a discussion. Douglas A. Warner III, the chair of Motorola's Governance and Nominating Committee and one of the non-executive directors, wrote to me on August 13th stating that "[w]e are actively engaged, and we have been and will continue to be proactive in implementing changes that we believe will enhance value for all Motorola stockholders." We respectfully would say that we are frustrated by the results of their current efforts to be engaged.
We appreciate Mr. Meredith's comments at Wednesday's Citigroup meeting with investors in which he ackowledged the company had made "mistakes" and that the two rounds of layoffs are "a symbol of management failure." Yet, we are puzzled why the board and management team have not been held accountable for their self-acknowledged failure. Why should the rank-and-file Motorolans bear the brunt of management's failure?
Here is my video question for Mr. Zander....
Posted by
Unknown
at
1:24 PM
1 comments
Labels: Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, Motorola, Plan B, Tom Meredith
From a Bloomberg article today by Ville Heiskanen.
As you know, I've been reaching out to MOT shareholders since launching the "Plan B" campagin in July. MTB was one of several companies who I contacted who had divested their shares before I reached them. The 2nd last sentence below referring to Brad Williams is telling and shared among many in the institutional investor community: "Williams says he won't buy Motorola stock unless he sees a recovery, or a change in CEOs that signals revitalized design and marketing efforts."
Sept. 6 (Bloomberg) -- Motorola Inc.'s Razr 2 mobile phone, a new, more expensive version of its three-year-old best seller, may not be enough for Chief Executive Officer Ed Zander to revive profits.
Motorola, the biggest U.S. mobile-phone maker, began selling the $250 Razr 2 last month. While the new device has a bigger screen and more storage for songs, it lacks features such as the touch screen found in Apple Inc.'s iPhone.
The Razr 2, based on the handset that analysts say accounts for a third of Motorola's phone sales, will fail to win buyers because they can get the original for free with a service contract, said Brad Williams, who helps manage $13 billion as MTB Investment Advisors in Baltimore.
``You put it on the table next to the old Razr, and you don't really see what you're paying the extra $250 for,'' Williams said. ``You put an iPhone on the table, and everyone sees immediately it's an iPhone.'' MTB sold its stake in Motorola last quarter and holds Apple shares.
Zander, 60, may discuss early results for the Razr 2 tomorrow when he meets with analysts and investors in New York. Shareholders including Carl Icahn have called for the CEO to step down if sales and profit margins don't recover by year-end.
Sales Fall
Fading popularity of the original Razr contributed to a 19 percent drop in sales in the three months ended June 30 and Motorola's second straight quarterly loss. The company said when it reported the results that the unprofitable handset business would improve in the second half.
Spokeswoman Jennifer Erickson declined to say how many new Razrs Motorola expects to sell. The Schaumburg, Illinois-based company says it sold more than 100 million of the original units.
Motorola shares have declined 16 percent this year, while Cupertino, California-based Apple has soared 61 percent and world market leader Nokia Oyj added 57 percent. Motorola fell 1 cent to $17.19 on the New York Stock Exchange yesterday.
When the half-inch-thick Razr came out in 2004, it cost $499 with a service contract. Motorola started chopping the price when rivals such as Espoo, Finland-based Nokia caught up with the sleek design and won customers with new models.
Price cuts came too quickly and ``ruined'' the Razr brand, said Al Ries, chairman of Ries & Ries, an Atlanta-based marketing strategy firm.
``The Razr is cheap,'' said Ries, a co-author of ``The Origin of Brands.'' ``You can't make it expensive by calling it Razr 2.''
Low Volume
AT&T Inc., the biggest U.S. phone company, sells the Razr 2 for $300. Verizon Wireless and Sprint Nextel Corp. offer it for $250. Two millimeters thinner than the original, it sports a two-megapixel camera for higher-resolution photos.
``I just don't see it as being a high-volume model at this point,'' said Lawrence Harris, an analyst at Oppenheimer & Co. in New York who is ranked highest in accuracy among communications-equipment analysts by StarMine Corp. He has a ``neutral'' rating on Motorola stock.
The iPhone went on sale June 29 for as much as $599. It combined Apple's best-selling iPod music player with a Web- browsing phone. The iPhone's touch screen and lack of keyboard make the Razr 2 look dated already, MTB's Williams said.
Apple yesterday raised more hurdles for the Razr 2 by slicing the price of the top iPhone by $200 to $399.
Williams says he won't buy Motorola stock unless he sees a recovery, or a change in CEOs that signals revitalized design and marketing efforts. ``They need significant change in the product road map,'' he said. ``Zander is under a lot of pressure.''
From the Financial Times:
By Maija Palmer in London and Paul Taylor in New York
Published: August 22 2007 20:54 Last updated: August 22 2007 20:54
Ed Zander could come under renewed pressure to step down as chief executive of Motorola on Thursday as new figures showed the handset maker lost more than seven percentage points of market share during the second quarter.
Motorola narrowly maintained its position as second-largest handset manufacturer – but its share of global sales fell to 14.6 per cent, from 21.9 per cent a year ago, according to estimates by Gartner, a research company.
By Anna Marie Kukec
Daily Herald Business Writer
akukec@dailyherald.com
Posted Thursday, August 16, 2007 in the Chicago Daily Herald
A Florida-based consultant said Wednesday he’ll continue his campaign to oust Motorola Chief Executive Ed Zander, despite what he called a brush-off from the Schaumburg company’s board.
Eric Jackson, president of Jackson Leadership Systems Inc., a governance consulting firm in Naples, Fla., said he has about 130 shareholders with collectively about 600,000 Motorola shares who support his plan to turn around the beleaguered company.
He submitted his plan to some board members and sought a meeting with them. Instead, he said he received a brief letter from the board on Wednesday.
Motorola executives have said they support Zander, and the board has not been looking to replace him. Calls and e-mails to Motorola were not returned Wednesday.
“I am now distributing this (his plan) to all the large shareholders I’ve been in touch with for the past month and am using this to call for more aggressive actions on the part of shareholders seeking change,” Jackson said.
Jackson, who owns about 100 Motorola shares, previously campaigned against former Yahoo CEO Terry Semel, who resigned under fire a few months ago. Jackson included videos about Semel on YouTube and a page on Flickr.com as part of that campaign. Jackson started a campaign against Zander after the company’s profits and global market share shrunk, more layoffs were announced and share value eroded.