Showing posts with label John Chapple. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Chapple. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Time for a Yahoo! Board Reboot

There's a great post from Kara Swisher this morning, which tips the cap to Sue Decker for stepping down from Yahoo! now and also calling for Roy Bostock to do the same. I want to second her sentiments.

Chairman Roy Bostock has repeatedly blown off criticisms of his botched handling of last year's Microsoft's negotiations by suggesting it was all because of Microsoft that a deal didn't get done.

He was dismissive of my suggestion at last August's annual meeting that he step down after 30+% of shareholders voted against his reelection in 2007. He said I was looking at it with a glass half-empty mentality. A few days later, we learned that well over 40% of shareholders voted against him at that August meeting. The figure would have been well over 50% had Carl Icahn's gold proxies from the previously called off proxy fight had been counted against Bostock.

If Carol Bartz wants to send the message that Yahoo! now has a performance culture, she should turn around and fire the guy who just hired her: Roy Bostock.

As Kara also says, she should then point her eyes on other directors. Gary Wilson and Ron Burkle -- like Bostock -- have received sizable protest votes from past annual meetings from investors. They came in weeks after Semel was hired (both are LA residents like Semel). Art Kern and Eric Hippeau have served on this board for over 12 years. That's not exactly a pair of fresh eyes they bring to the decision-making process. Finally, Kara suggests her sources said several directors wanted to be CEO. This is likely John Chapple and Maggie Wilderotter. They might also want to move on (even though they're relatively new to the group) to avoid any Bartz back-seat drivers.

Carol and Jerry need to hit "re-boot" to this board to really refresh this company.

Sphere: Related Content

Monday, July 28, 2008

Yahoo! Investors: Make Your Voices Heard

Friday's Yahoo! annual meeting for its shareholders will be an opportunity for us to speak up and make our voices heard.

If you're in the Bay Area, I encourage you to come out to the meeting at the Fairmont San Jose on Friday at 10am local time. (I will be traveling from the east coast to attend the meeting and know that several others are coming from long distances as well. Hopefully, we'll have a lively set of questions posed to the Yahoo! board in a true direct fashion since the titanic negotiations with Microsoft and also since Jerry Yang took over after last year's annual meeting.)

As I have said previously, I am "withholding" my votes for Roy Bostock, Ron Burkle, Art Kern, and Eric Hippeau. If more than 50% of my fellow shareholders do the same, those 4 men will have to submit their resignations (although Yahoo! could technically decline to accept them -- which would be highly unlikely because of the optics). I expect a Yahoo! board to be a better one without them than with them (although Yahoo! would be granted the right to select their successors -- hopefully only after much discussion with existing shareholders).

This morning, there was a story that at least one large YHOO shareholder was going to also vote "against" Jerry Yang. I can understand this sentiment. On a day when Yahoo! closed just shy of the ignominious price of $19, shareholders are understandably upset that CEO Yang couldn't close a deal to get 62% more than that a few weeks ago. In my opinion, Yang deserves a high "against" vote, but I hope he doesn't achieve the 50% mark because -- despite his failings this past year as CEO -- the company is better off with him on the board than without (in my opinion).

What about the Icahn nominees to the board?

We still don't know who 2 of these 3 people will be. The Yahoo! shareholders should have had the opportunity to vote on these nominees at this year's meeting. Instead, we'll have to wait a full year to vote.

However, this injustice is actually an opportunity. I hope that Yahoo! shareholders (large and small) will speak up in these last few days before Friday's meeting (and at Friday's meeting during the Q&A session) about their preferences for who should fill those slots.

Before the Yang-Icahn detente was struck, I had advocated a compromise solution in which I threw my support behind the election of John Chapple, Edward Meyer, Adam Dell, and Lucian Bebchuk. As part of the Icahn agreement, Carl himself will fill one of the 3 slots. Two are left open.

Jonathan Miller is rumored to be under consideration for one of those slots. He is an excellent choice and I would support him. Yet, he's still not thrown his hat in the ring.

If he passes on the chance to try and sort out this dysfunctional board from the inside, I would hope to see Chapple and Bebchuk elected.

Chapple (as Kara Swisher has said) has big business experience and wireless experience -- maybe he can sort out Yahoo! GO and help the company be successful in the perpetually burgeoning mobile wireless space. He also certainly knows how to sell out at the top. We'll see if he can help Yahoo! sell out when it's been round-tripped back to $19.

I also like Bebchuk and said so very early on. He's one of the best regarded academics on the issue of misaligned executive compensation and corporate performance. If you're going to try and cure Yahoo! of this affliction, why not send in the corporate equivalent of Doctors Without Borders?

We shouldn't be sitting back as shareholders waiting for Yahoo! to tell us who they -- in their infinite $19/share wisdom -- have deigned to select. Let's speak up and state who should be governing our company.

Sphere: Related Content