Canada's Real Estate Market Bubbly
By Eric Jackson
........
Eric Jackson's Blog About Longs, Shorts, Hedge Funds, Corporate Governance, and China
By Eric Jackson
NEW YORK (TheStreet) -- It has been painful to watch the housing turmoil in the last few years play out in the U.S. I know friends who have been terribly affected by it. After seeing the devastating impacts on the entire economy from this housing downturn, many market observers have pointed to China as a frothy real estate bubble that will likely pop soon. However, you might be surprised to learn that -- up until very recently -- there were bidding wars going on for homes in Canada.
Canada might be America's neighbor to the north, but it has a bubbly real estate market, even as the U.S. market continues to limp along. Consider these eye-raising facts:Canadians have been proud that their banks have done well post-Lehman, unlike so many of their global peers. The banks have actively originated mortgages demanded by Canadians over the last year, but -- unlike U.S. banks during the housing boom -- for the most part, they've elected not to hold on to these mortgages. As quickly as they can, they pass along the mortgages to the Canada Housing and Mortgage Corporation. This is a crown corporation, meaning it's 100% owned by the federal Canadian government (i.e., the Canadian taxpayers).
Over the last five years, the CHMC's liabilities -- meaning the mortgages they hold on their books -- have gone up five times from C$80 billion to C$400 billion. Any time you see a business increase its liabilities by that amount, it's intriguing. When you consider the last two years has been the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression, it's even more head-scratching.
However, Canada's economy was going along okay pre-Lehman. Whenthe stock market dropped, Canadian housing and real estate activity stopped and prices did drop. But, with most consumers and the Canadian banks in okay shape, and with Canadian job losses not as bad (relatively) as in the U.S., Canadian consumers had quicker confidence to spend thanks to the lower interest rates.When famous bear David Rosenberg left Merrill Lynch to move back to Canada in 2008 and join Gluskin Sheff, he spoke in glowing terms about Canada's position in the global economy. Yet, even he has begun to acknowledge the housing bubble that exists in Canada.
........
Posted by
Unknown
at
8:04 AM
View Comments
Labels: Canada, CM, David Rosenberg, Merrill Lynch, Real Estate, Ry, TD
By Eric Jackson, Senior Contributor
12/02/09 - 01:02 PM EST
Stock quotes in this article: BAC
NEW YORK (TheStreet) --
Reports are out today that several of the candidates under consideration for the top job at Bank of America(BAC Quote) have called on the board to consider breaking up the bank. They are having none of it. As a result, the CEO search for Ken Lewis' replacement continues.
All in all, you would have to give the board of Bank of America an "F" for how they've monitored management and succession planning since a firestorm enveloped the company last Fall.
Primarily blame for the lack of preparedness the board has shown to having a successor for Ken Lewis waiting in the wings lies at the feet of Hugh McColl, Lewis' predecessor. McColl has really shaped what Bank of America has grown into. It won't change until his ghost leaves the board by having directors he appointed step down.
On a "Frontline" episode from last year describing the financial meltdown, McColl, who is still the bank's chairman, recounted how he'd masterminded turning the small NCNB National Bank of North Carolina into the Bank of America juggernaut. He said that, as a company, "you're either growing or you're dying."
He took that advice to heart and did a series of acquisitions of companies to create a national titan in banking. And that's why it's unlikely this bank will break itself up now or while McColl is still around. It's just not in their corporate DNA.
Bank of America is the house the Hugh built. He hand-picked his board to be his lapdogs. He hand-picked his successor, Lewis, to carry on exactly in the fashion he had led the bank.
Lewis didn't miss a beat. In fact, he took it up a notch, making increasingly bigger acquisitions. Lewis' tenure as CEO will be defined by his acquisitions of MBNA, Fleet Bank, Countrywide, and Merrill Lynch. The bank is now enormous.Succession planning is only something a company is judged on when they do it badly. The fact that Bank of America is now having such a hard time filling the top spot signals how poorly equipped this board was to do scenario planning.
It's a pretty basic question that every board must always think about: what would we do tomorrow if the CEO got hit by a bus? Most of the time, there are two to three internal candidates' names which easily come to mind. Nine times out of 10, a board would rather select an internal candidate for the knowledge of the company, industry, customers, and employees who will be able to take the company forward.
All of the largest banks in America appear to have done a poor job of internal talent development, but Bank of America is by far the worst. Why?
At the end of the day, the bank's directors were charter members of the "Friends of Hugh" club. Their primary job as a director was to rubber-stamp whatever Hugh wanted to do. If Hugh didn't bring up the issue of succession planning, it didn't need to be considered.
That's why, starting after the spring shareholders' meeting (at which there were several directors who received large numbers of "against" votes) the Federal Reserve has started reassembling the board of directors. That's something we first started mentioning here over the summer.
This revamped board was still not able to get an effective succession process in place to prepare for Lewis' surprise departure. They should entertain all kinds of scenarios such as breaking up the bank. In my view, it epitomizes a "too-big-to-fail" financial institution and hasn't demonstrated that it can manage the disparity and scope of so many businesses.
If the Fed really wants to see the company change though, it should remove all directors who have ties to Hugh McColl. Once that happens, this board will start to rethink how this bank should be run from a truly fresh perspective. And they’ll probably conclude it does need to be broken up.
At the time of publication, Jackson did not have any position in the stock mentioned.Eric Jackson is founder and president of Ironfire Capital and the general partner and investment manager of Ironfire Capital US Fund LP and Ironfire Capital International Fund, Ltd.
Sphere: Related Content
Posted by
Unknown
at
1:15 PM
View Comments
Labels: BAC, Bank of America, CEO Succession, Countrywide, Fleet, Hugh McColl, Ken Lewis, MBNA, Merrill Lynch, Succession Planning
NEW YORK (Fortune) -- Is Bank of America really doing well enough to get off the government dole?
The Charlotte, N.C., bank is talking with regulators about repaying some of its $45 billion of Troubled Asset Relief Program debts, the Wall Street Journal reported Tuesday.
BofA (BAC, Fortune 500) wouldn't comment about the report. But it's no secret why the nation's biggest bank by assets might want to start wriggling out from under TARP.
Rivals, including JPMorgan Chase (JPM, Fortune 500), repaid the government in June, freeing them from congressional scrutiny. With that backdrop, the mere suggestion that BofA may be ready to write a check to the Treasury was well received by some analysts.
"We think that an initial payment signifies that [Bank of America] is not facing any major setbacks since reporting solid Q2 results," Standard & Poor's equity analysts wrote Tuesday, referring to the bank's better-than-expected profit in the second quarter.
Wall Street was skeptical, though. The stock was down 5% in midday trading Tuesday, a day when bank stocks broadly were leading a market sell-off. And whether BofA is really healthy enough to follow in the footsteps of its peers is an open question.
Though the economy has shown signs of recovering, skeptics contend it's too early for banks such as BofA -- which in January was under such financial stress that it was forced to announce it had lined up $138 billion in federal support -- to give money back to the government.
Whitney Tilson, a fund manager who is betting BofA stock will fall, said he believes the government shouldn't accept TARP repayment from big banks until the economic recovery is further advanced and the possibility of another downturn -- a so-called double-dip recession -- can be ruled out.
"The last thing you want is for banks to pay back money now and then need it later," he said. "You need to show you're really out of the woods. To me, that hurdle is a very, very high one."
To that end, Tilson questions the strength of the summer rebound in housing. He said he believes home prices nationwide aren't likely to hit bottom until next spring at the earliest -- which means more losses for banks such as BofA, which has $590 billion of consumer loans on its books.
There are other signs Bank of America could still be vulnerable should the market optimism that took the broader market up almost 50% fade.
While the bank has been setting aside more reserves for credit losses, problem loans have been growing even faster.
Since the second quarter of 2008, BofA has set aside $47.5 billion to cover credit losses, and its loan loss reserve has doubled. Yet its coverage ratio -- comparing the size of the loan loss reserve to the amount of nonperforming assets -- has dropped to 116% from 187% a year earlier.
And with unemployment at its highest level since the early 1980s, losses on credit card, commercial and residential loans are expected to keep rolling in through next year.
"It would be unwise for people to forget about the problems in their loan book," said Tilson. "They've got an awful lot of exposure."
To be sure, the bank -- like the rest of the economy -- looks a lot healthier than it did six months ago, when its shares traded at multidecade lows. Since then, BofA shares have risen sixfold, fueled in part by the bank's $7.5 billion first-half profit.
The rally has helped BofA raise nearly $40 billion in new capital, more than filling the hole noted in the government's stress test and seemingly bracing the institution against further problems.
Analysts at R.W. Baird wrote in June that the capital raise "should be adequate to enable the company to earn through the current cycle with a low likelihood of needing additional government capital."
Still, Bank of America shares fetch barely half the price they traded for a year ago -- which helps to explain another reason why Lewis might like to start repaying BofA's loans.
A partial TARP repayment would be a feather for Lewis to put in his cap after two unpopular and costly acquisitions, of the Countrywide mortgage and Merrill Lynch brokerage franchises. Shareholders stripped him of his chairmanship in April, largely out of frustration with his handling of the Merrill deal.
"In his mind, this is a good way to resuscitate his legacy," said Eric Jackson, an activist investor who runs hedge fund Ironfire Capital and has no position in Bank of America stock. "He wants people to say the Merrill Lynch deal did work out, the Countrywide merger is producing -- that's where his head is now." ![]()
Posted by
Unknown
at
9:53 PM
View Comments
Labels: Bank of America, BofA, Colin Barr, Countrywide, Eric Jackson, Fortune, Ironfire Capital, Ken Lewis, Merrill Lynch, TARP
There's something highly annoying about watching the blame game playing out over the last week, first with Ken Lewis blaming Hank Paulson and Ben Bernanke and, this morning, with John Thain getting in some licks against the guy who saved his firm from a Lehman-like outcome.
The press and shareholders often complain about the size of executive compensation (as well they should), but the truth is that execs and most notably CEOs (not unlike politicians) are driven by a more powerful motivation (especially towards the end of their careers): preservation and enhancement of their reputation and legacy.
What prompted Ken Lewis last week to point the finger at the US government for Bank of America's (BAC) troubles is the fact that he'll be facing the music this week at his shareholders' meeting. There will be a large number of highly respected shareholders voting against him and he might well follow Terry Semel's lead and resign a few days afterwards, if the votes against are large enough.
In Lewis' mind, his life's work (building up BAC into the world's largest financial supermarket -- no longer a positive -- buying FleetBoston, MBNA, Countrywide, and Merrill) is about to go by the boards with a negative vote. That would be even more devastating to him than losing his job or a paycheck.
Lewis is putting up his last defense in striking out at Paulson and Bernanke. Nothing personal guys, business is business.
For Thain, the situation is different. This is a guy that should have another good 15 years in front of him as a major financial services CEO. Now, that's in question since he decided to move up the Merrill bonuses last year and the whole office deco-gate.
In my view, neither man is coming off well with their latest accusations and both will have to spend more time in the penalty box. For Lewis, that might include a large mark is his career accomplishments after this week's vote.
Position: None.
Originally published in RealMoney on 4/27/2009 7:39 AM EDT.
For real-time updates, subscribe to RealMoney.com
Posted by
Unknown
at
8:22 AM
View Comments
Labels: BAC, Bank of America, John Thain, Ken Lewis, Merrill Lynch
By Eric Jackson
From TheStreet.com
01/23/09 - 09:08 AM EST
MER , BAC , C , GS (Cramer's Pick) , NYX , TYC , AAPL , JPM , GE
The stunning announcement of John Thain's departure from Bank of America (BAC Quote - Cramer on BAC - Stock Picks) yesterday, less than a month after merging Merrill Lynch (MER Quote - Cramer on MER - Stock Picks) into the bank would have been unthinkable a few weeks ago.
After announcing the shotgun marriage of Merrill Lynch with Bank of America in September, hours after Lehman Brothers collapsed, the sterling reputation of John Thain was cemented: This was a CEO who could do no wrong.
Revelations leaking out of Bank of America in the last few days, and Thain's departure today, alter his image -- perhaps irreparably. Observers now wonder how this quiet, smart overachiever could have shown such poor judgment. After all, this is a man who rose through the ranks at Goldman Sachs(GS Quote - Cramer on GS - Stock Picks), turned around the New York Stock Exchange(NYX Quote - Cramer on NYX - Stock Picks) and merged it with Euronext and then had headhunters and corporate boards falling over themselves offering him numerous CEO spots.
There are 5 puzzling decisions Thain has made in recent weeks that ended up being his undoing:
1. He decided to move up Merrill's bonuses which are typically paid in January to December, prior to the closing of the merger with BofA. The payouts amounted to $15 billion, only a 6% drop from last year. Bank of America sought an additional $20 billion from the Treasury days later (this after requesting a $10 million bonus for himself for 2008, which was rejected by his board).
2. He did not come to BofA CEO Ken Lewis immediately to disclose Merrill's fourth-quarter loss after a sharp erosion of Merrill's book of business.
3. He left New York to go on a family ski vacation in Vail at the time news broke about the Merrill bonuses.
4. He planned to attend the upcoming Davos meeting, even though the financial industry is once again under extreme strain and BofA has advised against it.
5. He reportedly ordered an expensive redecoration of the Merrill corporate offices using his personal decorator in early 2008 at the same time he was preaching cost cuts to his new employees. (Among the expenses reported: $87,000 for an area rug, $11,000 for a "Roman shade" and $243,000 in salary and bonuses for Thain's driver last year.)
The last detail prompted short-seller Doug Kass to draw comparisons with now-imprisoned former CEO of Tyco(TYC Quote - Cramer on TYC - Stock Picks), Dennis Kozlowski, who famously approved a $6,000 shower curtain for the corporate apartment he stayed at in New York. (Kozlowski actually looks frugal compared to Thain.)
What's interesting about to the comparison between Thain and Kozlowski is that both were highly regarded prior to these scandals. At the time of his hiring, new Merrill CFO Nelson Chai complemented Thain's intelligence: "When you're the smartest guy in the room, which he typically is, you come at things from a different altitude."
How could someone so smart, make these poor decisions? And if it can happen to Thain, who will be the next golden CEO to drop? How can you spot the next smart executive to fail?
Sydney Finkelstein, a Professor of Management at Dartmouth's Tuck School of Business with whom I've worked on consulting projects, published a 2004 business best-seller called "Why Smart Executives Fail" that looked at 60 successful CEOs who later failed, including Kozlowski, Enron's Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling and George Shaheen of dot-bomb Webvan. The book is a great read -- and very current, given what we're living through.
Finkelstein summarizes what he calls the "Seven Habits of Spectacularly Unsuccessful Executives." One of those habits seems very relevant to John Thain: "They identify so completely with the company that there is no clear boundary between their personal interests and their corporation's interests." This was the habit that derailed Kozlowski, in Finkelstein's opinion. Here's a brief except from the book on this trait:
"We want business leaders to be completely committed to their companies, with their interests tightly aligned with those of the company. But digging deeper, you find that failed executives weren't identifying too little with the company, but rather too much. Instead of treating companies as enterprises that they needed to nurture, failed leaders treated them as extensions of themselves. And with that, a 'private empire' mentality took hold.
"CEOs who possess this outlook often use their companies to carry out personal ambitions. The most slippery slope of all for these executives is their tendency to use corporate funds for personal reasons. CEOs who have a long or impressive track record may come to feel that they've made so much money for the company that the expenditures they make on themselves, even if extravagant, are trivial by comparison. This twisted logic seems to have been one of the factors that shaped the behavior of Dennis Kozlowski of Tyco. His pride in his company and his pride in his own extravagance seem to have reinforced each other."
In the case of Thain, he signed off on these expensive corporate renovations after Merrill "won" the battle to get him as CEO (remember Citigroup (C Quote - Cramer on C - Stock Picks) wanted him too). At the time he took over the company a year ago, he was one of the kings of Corporate America. He might well have felt justified in green-lighting these expenses and using his own decorator.
It's also interesting to note that, in all the criticism of how Ken Lewis of BofA failed to do sufficient due diligence on Merrill prior to announcing the deal, no one has criticized John Thain for insufficient due diligence on Merrill prior to taking the top job. At the time of his hiring, he assured the press that he'd been given complete access to Merrill's books. Apparently he did a poor review. When Merrill's fortunes started to go south, no one went back to ask Thain about this oversight.
What this sorry episode teaches all analysts, media, and investors is that we need to appreciate success and achievement but always remain skeptical. We shouldn't be afraid to ask tough questions even about "untouchable" CEOs like Apple's(AAPL Quote - Cramer on AAPL - Stock Picks) Steve Jobs, JPMorgan Chase's (JPM Quote - Cramer on JPM - Stock Picks)Jamie Dimon, or General Electric's(GE Quote - Cramer on GE - Stock Picks) Jack Welch. Past success no longer guarantees future success in today's world.
Unfortunately for BofA shareholders, no one had warning signs about Thain until the last 72 hours. (And let's not forget that, if you're a Merrill shareholder, you are overjoyed that Thain sold this company at such a premium and kept the fourth-quarter loss under wraps until the deal went through.)
One thing's for sure: If you're a company insider and you hear about a big corporate office renovation, starting looking for work and start selling your insider stock right away.
Neither Eric Jackson nor his fund owns stock in Merrill or BofA.
Posted by
Unknown
at
9:47 AM
View Comments
Labels: BAC, Bank of America, John Thain, Ken Lewis, Merrill Lynch, Sydney Finkelstein
TheStreet.com
By Eric Jackson
09/17/08 - 09:43 AM EDT
As we all try to digest the unprecedented volatility that has besieged the stock market this week, with Lehman Brothers (LEH Quote - Cramer on LEH - Stock Picks) and Merrill Lynch (MER Quote - Cramer on MER - Stock Picks) now washed away, there is one question that is often repeated: How could so many smart people get things so wrong? It wasn't hubris or laziness. It was the inability of the board members and CEOs to look at the problems facing their companies with fresh eyes.
Newcomers like John Thain at Merrill took decisive actions to create the maximum shareholder value under the circumstances. Old-time CEOs like Dick Fuld at Lehman and Robert Willumstad at AIG(AIG Quote - Cramer on AIG - Stock Picks), who is a new CEO but has been on AIG's board since 2006, dawdled, and their companies are now paying the price -- one with bankruptcy and the other agreeing to a government bailout last night.
Management theorists Don Hambrick and Danny Miller conducted a study on the seasons of a CEO's tenure 20 years ago. They found that CEOs had the freshest eyes early in their tenure. They revisited old decisions made by their predecessors and charted a course for the organization under their leadership. After only a few years though, the CEOs began running their companies from within the prism of their past decisions. If their strategy didn't work out, they would defend it, stating that it simply needed more time.
This tendency for defensively believing in past decisions is not a CEO condition -- it's a human condition. It's not a trait that gets noticed when times are good, but it can be a deadly trait in so-called "perfect storm" times like the one we're currently living in.
It's up to the boards to hold CEOs responsible for their decisions by questioning them when warranted. Sadly, that didn't happen in the case of Lehman and AIG. In the case of both, it cost them the companies.
In this environment, even the most gilded companies' CEOs -- such as Lloyd Blankfein of Goldman Sachs (GS Quote - Cramer on GS - Stock Picks) and John Mack of Morgan Stanley (MS Quote - Cramer on MS - Stock Picks) -- need to be questioned by their boards. Worst-case scenarios must be discussed and preparations made.
Just because a CEO has a long tenure at a company and holds the title of chief executive doesn't mean he or she will fail; it simply means he or she needs to be on guard against "conventional wisdom." Conventional wisdom a few months ago was that Lehman was no Bear Stearns.
Wachovia's (WB Quote - Cramer on WB - Stock Picks) new CEO, Robert Steel, appears to be using his financial industry experience (he formerly served as head of equities at Goldman and undersecretary of the Treasury), as well as his lack of Wachovia tenure, to make quick moves in downsizing and separating the good and bad aspects of the bank in his first couple of months on the job. It warrants watching if he can be successful in doing what's needed at that bank in comparison to Thain's moves at Merrill.
Vikram Pandit, the CEO of Citigroup (C Quote - Cramer on C - Stock Picks), deserves a lot of scrutiny. He came to Citi after his Old Lane hedge fund was acquired. So far, he has done little to separate himself from the model that Sandy Weill built and for which Chuck Prince acted as caretaker. Will Pandit be just another caretaker? How will Citigroup be defined under his tenure? We have yet to find out. In the meantime, the company's stock drifts lower with the industry, and Citigroup continues to pay a dividend it can't afford. There is no urgent capital-raising needed yet, but Pandit needs to have the pressure kept on him.
In these difficult times, all CEOs and directors must come to work each day with fresh eyes to confront the problems they face. No matter how much past success they've achieved, no matter how esteemed these CEOs are, Lehman and AIG have taught us how easily everything that it took generations to build can be lost.
There, but for the grace of God, go I.
Posted by
Unknown
at
12:52 AM
View Comments
Labels: AIG, Citigroup, Danny Miller, Don Hambrick, Eric Jackson, Goldman Sachs, Ironfire Capital, John Thain, Lloyd Blankfein, Merrill Lynch, Robert Steel, Robert WIllumsted, Vikram Pandit, Wachovia