Don’t Tell Mom, Cisco’s Board is Dead Asleep
John Chambers has got to go as Cisco CEO. For the last 4 years, he's been paid $56 million while the stock has dropped 35%. Here's what shareholders should do.
Read my full post at Forbes.
Eric Jackson's Blog About Longs, Shorts, Hedge Funds, Corporate Governance, and China
John Chambers has got to go as Cisco CEO. For the last 4 years, he's been paid $56 million while the stock has dropped 35%. Here's what shareholders should do.
Read my full post at Forbes.
Posted by
Unknown
at
12:18 PM
View Comments
Labels: Activist Investing, BearingPoint, Breakingviews, Brian Halla, Carol Bartz, Cisco, CSCO, Home Depot, John Chambers, NSM, Ralph Whitworth, Relational Investors, Rob Cox, Rod McGeary, Sprint, YHOO
Carl C. Icahn likes to be called an activist investor, not a raider. He has, however, just made a hostile bid for one company, and is in multiple court battles.
By JULIE CRESWELL
Published: March 21, 2010
The New York Times
HE is a billionaire several times over. He has spent the better part of four decades terrorizing corporate chiefs and battling entrenched boards. His name is emblazoned on a stadium on an island in the East River, a laboratory at Princeton, a science center at the Choate Rosemary Hall school in Connecticut and charter schools in the Bronx.
Yet, for all of his high-profile successes, Carl C. Icahn says he feels misunderstood.
"There's a misperception out there that we bust up companies. Or that I believe that all people on boards are bad," growls Mr. Icahn, the 74-year-old investor, as he sets a coffee cup on a small mahogany table in his office on the 47th floor of a Midtown Manhattan tower. "It's just that, in some cases, the C.E.O.'s are so wrong," he grumbles, then quickly flashes a big smile and laughs at his own joke.
While Mr. Icahn likes to pull out his Rodney Dangerfield-esque why-can't-I-get-any-respect? routine, he has over the years perfected the art of stirring up trouble for companies and making money - sometimes lots of it - for his investors and himself.
And while many of his peers from back in the day - names including T. Boone Pickens, Saul P. Steinberg, Robert M. Bass - keep significantly lower profiles these days, Mr. Icahn has not gone quietly into the night.
"He is a survivor," said Chris Young, a director at Institutional Shareholder Services, a Rockville, Md., proxy advisory firm. "If you look at the proxy pipeline, he's involved with a bunch of contentious situations."
On Friday, Mr. Icahn made a hostile offer to buy the Hollywood studio Lionsgate Entertainment; meanwhile, through the $8 billion hedge fund and other assets he oversees - $6 billion is his money - he is waging proxy fights to get new or additional board seats at the biotech companies Biogen Idec and Genzyme.
They are also warring with Donald Trump and debt holders in a New Jersey bankruptcy court over ownership of three casinos in Atlantic City that bear Mr. Trump's name.
In recent months, Mr. Icahn has bought a partly built casino on the Las Vegas strip and the Tropicana Casino and Resort in Atlantic City from bankruptcy.
It is too early to tell whether he will prevail in these battles. But after all these years, a career of victories and occasional misses, one thing can certainly be said of Mr. Icahn: He is one of Wall Street's most colorful, controversial and complicated characters.
Wearing slightly rumpled khakis and waving his eyeglasses to punctuate key points, Mr. Icahn is constantly jumping from one topic to another in an endless stream of dialogue. In that respect, he more closely resembles an absent-minded professor than a master of the universe. Corporate executives visiting his offices walk through hallways adorned with paintings of battle scenes and sculptures of cowboys on bucking broncos. One large painting in the conference room features a lion gazing at the bones of an animal in a desert.Yet he bristles at being labeled a "raider," despite the fact that he is widely viewed as a founding member of the clan that roamed Wall Street in the 1980s, occasionally pursuing hostile takeovers with ruthless abandon.
He prefers to paint his role in those years with the same "activist investor" brush he holds today, arguing that he has created tens of billions of dollars of value for shareholders in companies in which he invested. (In conversations, he declares that he has created $30 billion, $40 billion and even $50 billion worth of value for shareholders. What is a few billion among friends?)
Last year, his hedge fund, highly concentrated in a handful of stocks and bonds, soared 32 percent, after fees, according to a letter sent to investors. That's a reversal from 2008, when it fell 36 percent, including fees. Mr. Icahn's firm declined to provide an after-fees figure.
To some people, Mr. Icahn and activist investors of his ilk are the heroes of the financial system. "They are the ones who are holding corporate America's feet to the fire and incentivizing companies to perform better," said Frank Partnoy, a professor of law and finance at the University of San Diego. Mr. Partnoy contributed to a study that examined activist investing from 2001 to 2006 and found that activists held stocks longer than others and that the companies they pursue often outperform the market. But some fellow activists contend that Mr. Icahn's strong-armed methods of arguing to get on a board and then pushing for a quick change - such as paying a dividend, buying back stock, merging with another company or cleaving off an underperforming unit - are sadly out of date in today's corporate boardrooms. "There are times when you push back and be harsh and times when you roll up your sleeves and work with management, getting more involved with operations," said Eric Jackson, an activist investor in Naples, Fla. "Carl's record on that score hasn't been as successful."
Mr. Icahn and his defenders say he has improved several companies he has invested in or owns. (Besides the hedge fund, he oversees Icahn Enterprises, a hodgepodge of companies he has collected over the years in the automotive, metals and real estate industries.) Late one recent Friday afternoon, Mr. Icahn, a workaholic night owl who rarely appears at glittering high-society functions, dismissed thoughts about going out to dinner with his wife, Gail, or - gasp - taking a bigger break from the business altogether. "What else am I going to do?" Mr. Icahn asked before returning to his office for a meeting on his real estate holdings. "Play shuffleboard?"
IN the spring of 2008, Roy J. Bostock, the chairman of Yahoo, and his fellow directors were coming under a barrage of criticism from investors after Microsoft abruptly broke off merger talks. Mr. Icahn, who had a large stake in Yahoo, jumped into the fray. In a scathing letter to Mr. Bostock, he said the board had "acted irrationally" and "completely botched" the merger. Mr. Icahn's solution included putting up a slate of 10 directors picked by him. (The company eventually settled, placing Mr. Icahn and two of his other nominees on the 11-member board.) What Mr. Icahn did or did not accomplish in his 15 months on the Yahoo board - he stepped down last fall - is the subject of hot debate. But what's surprising about that debate is that one of Mr. Icahn's biggest detractors is Mr. Jackson, a fellow activist investor. And his biggest supporters are some other Yahoo directors.
"I think in the first couple of meetings, there was a lot of trepidation: Will he just be disruptive and not constructive? Can this work?" said Maggie Wilderotter, the C.E.O. of Frontier Communications, who resigned from Yahoo's board last year. "Carl doesn't worry about what people around the table think about him. He's blunt. If there's an elephant in the room, he puts it on the center of the table." And while Mr. Bostock recalled with humor at least one conversation with Mr. Icahn that involved many "four-letter words going back and forth," he said he appreciated Mr. Icahn's persistence and the different point of view he brought to discussions.
"Carl brought financial acumen to the board and a good, solid understanding of the strategic imperatives that faced the company, particularly what it would take to compete longer term with the likes of Google, Microsoft and others from a capital-expenditures point of view," Mr. Bostock said. "It was one of the reasons he was pushing for a Microsoft deal."
But Mr. Jackson, who manages a small activist hedge fund called Ironfire Capital, says Mr. Icahn blew it with Yahoo.
"There was a sense that shareholders were going to go to Sunnyvale with pitchforks," Mr. Jackson said, referring to Yahoo's California base. "He saw that and thought he could ride in on a horse and take control of the company. He didn't realize that he had to articulate to investors what it was he was going to do if he actually had the keys to the car and was driving things." "He's the granddaddy of activist investing. Anyone who practices activist investing has to pay homage to him and the trail that he's blazed," Mr. Jackson added. But "I would say his involvement with the company did nothing for shareholders and hurt his own investors in the stock."
Mr. Icahn said that while his firm did not make money in Yahoo, it was supportive in bringing on board Carol Bartz, the company's C.E.O., and instrumental in eventually forging an Internet search and advertising partnership with Microsoft. As for the criticism from Mr. Jackson that his methods do not work, Mr. Icahn said, "To say that we don't add value is absurd."
MR. ICAHN grew up in a middle-class neighborhood in Queens, and started his first business at the age of 13, when he snapped pictures of neighbors' homes. He developed the photographs in his basement and glued them to the covers of matchbooks that he would buy for 50 cents a box. He sold the boxes to homeowners for $1.50. When he turned 15, he played his own version of the ice futures market as a cabana boy at a beach club, ordering extra ice on hot mornings to sell to visitors who would run out later in the day. After graduating from Princeton with a degree in philosophy and briefly serving as a medic in the Army, Mr. Icahn landed on Wall Street, opening his own brokerage firm in 1968. In the late 1970s, he waged his first proxy battles.
When the buyout barons and corporate raiders ruled Wall Street in the 1980s, he was one of the kings. He made plays for some of the largest companies in America, including Phillips Petroleum, the steel giant USX, Texaco and T.W.A. Some were big victories for Mr. Icahn; others were perhaps more trouble than they were ultimately worth.
"He had a very devil's-advocate way of reviewing investments," said Gary Siegler, who worked with Mr. Icahn from 1985 to 1990. "You had to be able to support your point of view."
After the junk bond market collapsed and boards adopted anti-takeover measures, some raiders moved on in the early 1990s to other things. Mr. Icahn stayed the course, battling for control of the comic book publisher Marvel Entertainment and badgering RJR Nabisco to split its food and tobacco units. Some of his fights in recent years have involved technology and entertainment companies, including Time Warner, Motorola, Blockbuster and the video game maker Take-Two Interactive Software. "He's had a mixed record on returns" and in understanding the evolution of the media business, said Matthew Harrigan, an analyst at research firm Wunderlich Securities who is watching Mr. Icahn's moves against Lionsgate. Among other things, Mr. Icahn is angling to get his son and fellow chess player, Brett, who works at Mr. Icahn's company, on the studio's board.
Associates of Mr. Icahn say that his company made money on its Time Warner investment and that while his Motorola investment has not gone as well, they believe it will eventually pay off.
"We hold these things for a long time and the jury is still out," Mr. Icahn added.He has fared better in some of his biotech holdings, which make up a big chunk of the hedge fund's investments.
"The biotechs have been his big winners recently," particularly investments in ImClone Systems and MedImmune, said Mr. Young at Institutional Shareholder Services. "His thesis, which is no secret, is that biotech firms should be purchased by Big Pharma, which is always in need of new products. In his mind, that's a match made in heaven." Mr. Icahn says he has also made money in industrial and gambling companies he has acquired out of bankruptcy and nursed back to health.
He said that a couple of years ago, for instance, his company booked a $1 billion profit after selling gambling properties, including the Las Vegas Stratosphere hotel and casino, that it had picked up largely in bankruptcy proceedings. Similarly, he made an additional $1 billion or so selling energy companies he had acquired years earlier.
In those cases and others, Mr. Icahn argues that he is not given enough credit for holding companies for long periods and investing even more of his own money into the businesses to help them grow. He specifically cites his investments in a rail-car business and the automotive parts supplier Federal-Mogul. "What gives me the greatest excitement and joy is building a company," Mr. Icahn said. "By the way, it's also the way to make the most money."It may not, however, be the easiest way to make a buck. One of the companies in which he owns a majority stake - XO Communications - has been fighting lawsuits by R2, a Fort Worth, Tex., fund controlled by a hedge fund called Q Investments. The hedge fund is run by Geoffrey Raynor, a former investment banker who worked for the Bass family of Texas. R2 accuses Mr. Icahn of engaging in "sweetheart" transactions and "self-dealing" in his oversight of the communications company.
In another suit against Mr. Icahn, Mr. Raynor, through another fund, contends that "material misinformation" was included in a recent $2 billion bond offering. Mr. Raynor declined to comment for this article.Mr. Icahn, who denies all of the accusations made against him, filed his own $100 million lawsuit against Mr. Raynor recently, saying Mr. Raynor's lawsuit caused economic harm to the bond offering. Mr. Icahn called Mr. Raynor a "serial sue-er," and in a court document he contends that the hedge fund has filed 45 lawsuits against various parties in the last four years.Disputing that figure, a spokesman for Mr. Raynor says that in the last 10 years, the firm has been a plaintiff in 16 non-bankruptcy proceedings, along with the two legal disputes with Mr. Icahn.
"I've put $1 billion into this company. I don't get a salary, and I spend hours on it each week," Mr. Icahn said, his tone rising in frustration. "About $80 million of the company's revenues each year are coming from introductions I brought in."
Later, as further proof of his involvement with the communications company he proudly showed off the latest addition to a row of awards arrayed on a cabinet just outside his office. It is a large glass cup engraved with his name, declaring him XO's "salesman of the decade."
LATE last year, Donald Trump was sitting in his office when he was alerted that Carl Icahn was on the phone. Mr. Icahn told him that he had joined the Texas banker D. Andrew Beal in his effort to gain control of three Atlantic City casinos bearing Mr. Trump's name, acquiring a majority of the first-lien mortgages held by Beal Bank."He told me he was doing it because he heard I wasn't involved, but he knew I was involved, that I had a deal with bondholders," Mr. Trump said. "I was very surprised and also very disappointed that Carl got involved," Mr. Trump added. He said the two had been friends for years and that Mr. Icahn had sought his advice when he was divorcing his first wife. Mr. Trump said the two had not spoken since the call."I should be the one that is surprised he is upset," Mr. Icahn said. "I might possibly feel bad had I interfered at a time when he was running the business," but that's not the case, he added. "Additionally I find it odd that he's now claiming to be my good friend," Mr. Icahn said. "I was not surprised when I was not invited to his daughter's wedding precisely because we are not good friends."
The Trump casino deal shows that Mr. Icahn is not afraid to take on big names if there is money to be made. He also makes it clear in other dealings that he is aggressive in protecting his interests.
Consider the case involving the activist manager William A. Ackman. Mr. Ackman's fund, Gotham Partners, has sued a company owned by Mr. Icahn over a profit-sharing agreement between the men that was made about seven years ago.
According to court documents, Mr. Ackman sold his investment in Hallwood Realty to Mr. Icahn in 2003 with an agreement that if the assets were sold or transferred at a profit within three years, Mr. Ackman and his fund would get a share of the action. The assets were sold about a year later and, in an interview, Mr. Ackman said Mr. Icahn owed him about $4.7 million. The New York Supreme Court found in favor of Mr. Ackman, and the First Department appellate court affirmed that decision. Mr. Icahn has not paid any of the money and is disputing the legal fees, which with interest bring the total owed to $8 million Mr. Ackman said. "I call it my Carl Icahn money market account," he said. "I don't get these sort of rates anywhere else." Mr. Icahn responded that "I never agreed to give him the profit he now claims, and the case will be appealed."
Mr. Icahn does not seem to let anything, including a very close friendship, get in the way of protecting his and his investors' profits. Late in 2008, through his hedge fund, he sued Realogy, a real estate company controlled by Leon Black, the head of the private equity firm Apollo Management. Mr. Black was trying to reduce Realogy's hefty debt load by offering to exchange some of the debt with bondholders. Mr. Icahn, a bondholder who has known and been friends with Mr. Black for decades - the two have been longtime tennis partners - objected to some terms of the exchange and sued.
"Carl and I have been good friends for over 25 years," Mr. Black said in an e-mail message. "Occasionally we skirmish as couples are wont to do, but I believe we both feel that when the chips are down that the friendship is paramount."
How, exactly, does one sue and still be good friends with someone on Wall Street? Mr. Icahn smiles sagely over his cup of coffee: "The two of us have a saying that we always use whenever there is friction in our business dealings. We always say, 'there's only one Maltese Falcon.' "At one point in that classic 1941 film, a character chasing a valuable figurine says to a close associate, "You've been like a son to me," Mr. Icahn explains, paraphrasing from the movie.Then, lowering his voice with mock intensity, Mr. Icahn adds that the character says that if you lose a son, it's possible to get another - "but there's only one Maltese Falcon.' "
Posted by
Unknown
at
11:00 PM
View Comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Bill Ackman, Carl Icahn, chris young, Corporate Governance, Eric Jackson, icahn partner, Ironfire Capital, Maggie Wilderotter, Roy Bostock, Yahoo
By Eric Jackson, Senior Contributor
Last week, I got a chance to hear a speech by William Ackman, the CEO and founder of hedge fund Pershing Square Capital Management. If you're not familiar with this activist investor you should be, because his investment approach offers some valuable lessons.
Ackman's been in the news a lot over the past year or so.| Bill Ackman, CEO of Pershing Square Capital Management. |
He took a long position in General Growth Properties(GGWPQ.PK Quote) in November 2008 and then watched the stock go from 35 cents to more than $13. The company is now the subject of a bidding war between Simon Property(SPG Quote), Brookfield Asset Management(BAM Quote) and possibly Westfield and Vornado Realty Trust(VRO Quote)
He also ran a high-profile proxy contest against Target(TGT Quote) last year that failed to win him a seat on the retailer's board, although Target's shares are still still up substantially since he launched the contest.
Unlike most funds run by activist investors, Ackman's is not a long-only fund. He typically holds eight to 10 positions, with a couple of those being short. Because of that positioning, he's done well over the last few years and has remained active and outspoken.
Always a good speaker, Ackman has definitely ramped up his media appearances over the past couple of years. Pershing Square now manages more than $6 billion in assets, with a team of six investment professionals including Ackman.
Ackman describes the fund's strategy as "concentrated, fundamental, research-intensive, and long-short." The fund charges investors 1.5% in annual management fees and 20% in incentive fees.
Pershing Square has averaged 24% annualized returns since its founding in 2002. At the moment, the fund is 23% in cash.
It never uses leverage and almost never invests in industries that use a lot of leverage, are highly sensitive to interest-rate shifts or are commodity-related. (According to Ackman, the one investment that violated this rule was Borders(BGP Quote), which has lost 95% of its value since Ackman invested in it, although Ackman says at these levels it's a great value.)
Ackman wouldn't describe his firm's strategy as activist, either on the long side when he's gone to battle with Target or on the short side such as with bond insurer MBIA(MBI Quote), which Pershing Square first shorted in 2002.
......
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:02 AM
View Comments
Labels: Activism, Activist Investing, Bill Ackman, Borders, Brookfield Asset Management, General Growth Properties, MBIA, Pershing Square, Simon Property Group
I recently chatted with Matt Davio (@Misstrade) about activist investing, Microsoft (MSFT) and more. Thanks, Matt, for the opportunity to talk.
Eric Jackson @ericjackson part 1 and MissTrade Talk Activist Investing from miss trade on Vimeo.
Eric Jackson @ericjackson Part 2 Activist Investing from miss trade on Vimeo.
Sphere: Related Content
Posted by
Unknown
at
2:09 PM
View Comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Corporate Governance, Matt Davio, Misstrade
Posted by
Unknown
at
6:56 PM
View Comments
Labels: Activism, Activist Investing, Alcoa, Apple, Bank of America, Citigroup, Eric Jackson, GE, Ironfire Capital, Microsoft, RBS, State Street, Whole Foods, Yahoo
From TheStreet.com:
By Eric Jackson
12/11/08 - 09:59 AM EST
With the market's tumultuous last few months driving down the price of equities, activist investors around the world have seen their stock investments take major hits.
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:12 AM
View Comments
Labels: Activism, Activist Investing, Arthur Levitt, Bill Ackman, Carl Icahn, Greenlight Capital, J-Power, Pershing Square, Relational Investors, SEC, Sprint, Take Two, Yahoo
by Mark Glaser, 12:34PM
Feb. 21, 2008
If you’re following the twists and turns of Microsoft’s hostile bid for Yahoo, you can’t escape one name that keeps popping up in the media: Eric Jackson. As an activist shareholder in Yahoo, he has become the voice of the opposition, calling on Yahoo to accept Microsoft’s takeover bid — or any reasonable bid. Last year, he was instrumental in raising a ruckus online over Yahoo’s poor stock performance, and helped get Yahoo CEO Terry Semel ousted.
But what’s amazing about Jackson is that unlike the big-name activist shareholders such as Carl Icahn and Daniel Loeb who have huge war chests to buy up stock, Jackson is a small fish. He only owns 96 shares of Yahoo stock. Where Jackson has innovated is in using the tools of social media to gather support from other shareholders and get the attention of the media to make his case for corporate change.
He started in the summer of 2006 with a blog called Breakout Performance to tout his corporate consulting business. After a blog post about Yahoo attracted more traffic than his theses about corporate governance, Jackson began his campaign to get Yahoo to change its strategy, a “Plan B for Yahoo” that was eventually loaded onto a wiki. He shot some videos and uploaded them to YouTube, and used a web widget called YouChoose.net to get people to pledge their Yahoo shares to his cause. Last June, Jackson went to Yahoo’s annual shareholder meeting to confront Semel in person.
After enough people voted “no confidence” in Semel and some board members at that meeting, Semel stepped down from the CEO post a week later. Jackson justifiably took credit for leading the charge against Yahoo management in the media and online. Later, he followed in the footsteps of financier Carl Icahn in calling for Motorola CEO Ed Zander to step down — albeit with much less money invested in Motorola than Icahn, with just 134 shares. But even though Zander did vacate the CEO post, Motorola’s stock continues to hover near its historic low point.
So how did Jackson, 35, with a PhD in business management from Columbia University, get so much attention with so little stock in those companies? In a wide-ranging Q&A, Jackson explained how the media was drawn to him as the consistent “other side” of Yahoo’s financial story — plus, he had the social media hook, too.
“When I launched the campaign [against Yahoo], I thought I could write about it on my blog,” he said. “But if I was a reporter [covering this], what would make this story interesting to me? Some guy writing a blog is not that interesting. A blog is great, but what if I also did a YouTube video and tried to use more social media? Then it wasn’t just a David and Goliath, individual-investor-rising-up story, but it’s also a novelty, new technology, social media story. I had never used YouTube before, so I went out and got a $30 webcam and hooked it up to my laptop and recorded myself speaking my blog post.”
But Jackson found out that social media was more than just a good story angle to get press coverage. Eventually, he got 100 Yahoo investors to pledge their shares to his Plan B cause through YouChoose.net. People helped give valuable feedback to his Motorola Plan B on a wiki, and a Facebook group helped spread the word about his actions.
Jackson has parlayed his success with Yahoo into a new activist investment firm he runs called Ironfire Capital, though it has less than $5 million in funding so far, he said. Jackson is convinced that other individual investors will take similar coordinated online actions against companies that are underperforming, bringing a democratization and decentralization of power to corporate governance similar to what’s happening to the media industry.
The following is an edited transcript of our phone conversation and email correspondence, touching on Jackson’s action last year against Yahoo and his current push for shareholders to accept Microsoft’s bid.
As an investor, what is your strategy? Do you hold the stock for a longer period of time or sell it after you turn it around?
Jackson: I typically hold stocks for one to two years. So there’s an expectation that I’m not someone who’s trading in and out, I’m a holder of the stock and I have the long-term interest of the company in mind. I’d like to see the value of that company increase over that time. If it does on its own accord, that’s great, and if I do get involved as an activist, I’d expect that the effects of that activism would be realized in the stock price over that one-to-two-year time period.
Activism doesn’t have to be public and critical. It can also be quiet and private. The philosophy is that if you speak up, and you can make some compelling arguments, then other shareholders will pay attention and agree with you. You can end up, as a very small shareholder, with less than 1 percent, having an argument that ends up being followed and believed in by quite a number of shareholders, thereby pressuring the board to make those changes.
How did you initially decide to take on Yahoo?
Jackson: I was watching Yahoo from afar as an individual shareholder in the fall of 2006 and was really disenchanted with the direction of the company. I said to myself, ‘Here’s a perfect target for an activist investment firm’ and it got me to thinking. Even though I didn’t have an $8 billion investment firm, I thought that the chances were good that there were other investors like me who were upset. And I thought I could use social media, I had started a blog just six months before that. I thought, with blogs in the political realm, there are examples of people coming together with a grassroots movement behind a political candidate, and suddenly this phenomenon brings a tremendous amount of attention to that particular candidate and adds to that momentum.
I thought, ‘Why couldn’t that happen in a shareholder context if you had a company like Yahoo that is well known and well followed and people have passionate opinions about it?’ No one would have cared if I went after a shipyard company. Yahoo is kind of like the Paris Hilton of the business media, it seems like magazines and newspapers love writing about Yahoo.
When you started the blog was it for Yahoo in particular or was it for other reasons?
Jackson: I started the blog for other reasons. I was a strategy and governance consultant, and I still do that today. I started the blog as a way to write about topics that I consult on [so] it could bring more visibility to me and my consulting firm. I started it in the summer of 2006 without getting much traffic at all. I noticed that certain topics would suddenly get more traffic than others. I had written a post about Yahoo kind of randomly, making the point about leadership in general, [writing about] Terry Semel, the CEO from 2001, after Yahoo had crashed from the dot-com bubble. He had been getting credit in 2004 and 2005 as being the steady hand, gray hair, Hollywood exec who showed the kids what leadership was and how a real organization should be run. And he was the reason Yahoo got out of its swoon.
But in my eyes, observing what he had done, it didn’t seem that Yahoo had succeeded because of his leadership, but more in spite of it. What happened at Yahoo, the recovery, would have happened no matter who was in his position because of the general resurgence in the Internet and the advertising market. That blog post generated a lot of hits and comments, and that was interesting to me. It’s a high profile company and a lot of people care about it, so if you started a campaign about it you could tap into passionate people.
So because you didn’t have a lot of money invested in Yahoo, was the motivation for your activism to make a point about leadership?
Jackson: Initially I bought 45 years of Yahoo, and then I bought 51 more shares, so today I own 96 shares of Yahoo. So that’s worth about $2,500, so clearly it’s not about the money. When I started it, I had no idea if I would be successful or not. The reason I did it was to see if I could get people engaged. Truly what I was hoping for was to get some people together and put a plan together for what Yahoo should do if we were running the company, and maybe we could meet with them and they would agree to implement one or two ideas. And if that happened we could claim victory and show we made a difference. And it would be the first of its kind, where individual investors took this idea of activism and got a company to change.
I started a Facebook group, and later on, someone from the company Wikia contacted me and said, ‘This is cool that you have a Plan B for Yahoo.’ I had put up a seven-point plan on my blog and invited people to comment or criticize it or add to it. I was hoping it would further engage people in the group. They would feel they were part of the process and other people would have better ideas than me, too. That’s one of the tenents of Web 2.0, that the group is smarter than any individual.
So the people from Wikia said, ‘We could set up a wiki for you and people could more easily edit that.’ So we added that to the mix a few weeks later, and someone from a company called YouChoose.net contacted me. They encourage people who want to start a petition or cause to go to the site and get people to join their cause. They said they could help me create a widget for my site so people who want to join the cause could put in their information, say how many Yahoo shares they own, and it would instantly go into this graph showing support over time.
All those things were novel and added to the campaign. Immediately we had 25 people pledge with 50,000 Yahoo shares to the group in the first week. And the New York Times, Dow Jones and Red Herring wrote articles about it. It was a virtuous circle where someone would write about it in the press, and then people would go to the site and pledge shares, and then after more people signed up, the press would write more about it. It slowly built up over the coming weeks.
How did you know that these people really were Yahoo shareholders? Did you verify it in some way?
Jackson: It’s an honor system, but we follow-up with them later to verify. We have had bogus pledges in the past. Usually, they’re easy to spot because they have a very high number of shares and have a funny name for the pledger. In those cases, we follow-up with them by email and ask them to verify it. If they don’t respond, we delete their pledge.
We ask them for name, full contact info, shares owned, when purchased, etc. We haven’t made them sign legal docs or ask them to send us photocopies of shares. We simply put the detailed list together and receive verification from them that they represent that they truly own their shares.
Were the Web 2.0 things actually working at spreading the word or were they just helping in getting attention in the press?
Jackson: I had the feeling through the whole campaign and even now, I really feel it’s so early
days with this. I really believe in five years, activism will happen almost exclusively over the Internet. There will be forum groups and not just Yahoo Finance boards where people complain and say, ‘The people who run companies are bums.’ They will really exchange ideas with video messages and people will become more sophisticated as individual shareholders.
Did it matter? Yes it mattered, but we just got glimpses about how much it could matter. When I first put the Yahoo Plan B on the wiki we didn’t get many comments. It had been up on my blog before the wiki and people had left comments on the blog; some liked it and some criticized it.
Last fall, though, I did a wiki for a campaign with Motorola, and in that case I used the wiki right from the beginning and we got quite a few constructive comments on the wiki. So the tool was important, and it wasn’t just about having a nice story. There were some tools that were less valuable. The Facebook group, we could get people to join it, but there wasn’t much more they could do. We referred people from there to the blog, and it was a way for people to hear about us, but there wasn’t really an exchange of ideas there. That was an example of a tool that the press mentioned but it didn’t make that much of a difference.
You mentioned that the Yahoo campaign was the first case of individual investors making a big difference at a public company. Was that what happened last year with Terry Semel leaving the company?
Jackson: Yes, that’s what happened. There have always been activist investors at companies. They’re usually called gadflies, they are usually old ladies or old men who show up at annual shareholder meetings and shake their fists and cause a scene. At the end of the day they are only representing themselves so they are usually forgotten. This was the first time that an individual investor — not an institutional investor — assembled a group and voiced an opinion and had other people listen to it, and many people agreed with it and it definitely had an effect.
Leading up to the annual meeting in June last year, Yahoo did invite me to meet with them at their office. I did visit them and met with the general counsel, Michael Callahan, and a couple people who worked for him. I was hoping it would be this meeting where they might agree with two of our nine points, and we could be really happy. But it turned out, they were very cordial, and they just listened to me presenting our positions. But they didn’t really do anything afterwards.
Because of that non-action, I encouraged other shareholders to vote against board members at the annual shareholder meeting in June. They have a rule that if any one director got less than 50% support from shareholders, they would have to resign. So my hope was that if we got a substantial ‘no’ vote then Yahoo would have to listen to that as a big sign of shareholder dissatisfaction. So I spoke out, and was interviewed in the press because I spoke out, and I created a couple YouTube videos that I modeled after negative political campaign ads, saying why you should vote ‘no’ on a proposition or against someone. They were half-humorous but effectively delivered the message.
All the big institutions would say to me, ‘Listen Eric, we’re not going to join your group because we don’t do that, but we think what you’re doing is great, we’re making similar points ourselves to the Yahoo management, so keep their feet to the fire!’ At the annual meeting, there was a large ‘against’ vote. Some of the directors got 33% or 35% against votes, which is quite high for those types of votes. We were effective as an individual shareholder group, because we voiced a strong opinion and did it in a professional way. It wasn’t in a way that people could dismiss as crazy, ‘Oh don’t pay any attention to them.’ Our group did get 2.1 million shares pledged to our group, which is a lot but still was only 0.2% of total Yahoo shares outstanding.
When doing a campaign like this, if you don’t have the financial muscle, I guess the media exposure is really important.
Jackson: For sure. The media exposure was as important as the actual people who supported the campaign. In the days leading up to the annual meeting, a lot of press people were writing stories or doing TV pieces in anticipation of the meeting. And everyone in the press wants to give both sides to the story. For every story about a company there is the company line, and then an analyst saying why it isn’t that great. So I became kind of the natural person they ended up calling for the opposite view.
CNBC interviewed me the day before the meeting, I had this five minute interview. It was funny, when I went to the annual meeting, I saw the Yahoo general counsel [Callahan], who I had met in April, and he came over to me with this smile on his face. ‘How were you able to do all this? We sat around yesterday in the board room and saw you on CNBC and couldn’t believe it. How did you do that? Did you hire a PR firm?’ There’s no question the media exposure helped.
There’s a snowball effect where other media people see you quoted and then they call you to get a quote too.
Jackson: Yes, you gain legitimacy through the prior coverage in the press. And it feeds on itself. In the last week, I took this Yahoo group that had 100 shareholders and I’ve talked to several of them last week. We were all nervous that Yahoo would reject Microsoft’s offer, which they did. We believe that Jerry Yang doesn’t like Microsoft and doesn’t want to sell their baby to Microsoft and we were nervous as shareholders that they would try to sell us on staying independent, and we didn’t think that was smart. Rather than sit back and hope, we wanted to be part of the debate and hope it would resonate with other shareholders. We said we want to do a deal now, whether it’s from Microsoft or someone else.
I typed up a blog post and recorded a video and put it up there and contacted some people in the press and they wrote about it. It’s interesting the way people portrayed me this year vs. last year. They gave us a lot more weight than they did before. So I guess it builds on itself, and in six months they would give us even more legitimacy.
Why do you think Yahoo should take the offer from Microsoft?
Jackson: When I got involved last year, I thought Yahoo had great potential to stay independent. They have great people, great engineering talent, and great traffic, too. So that’s why it was so frustrating seeing them bumble around. I was hoping an activist campaign would shake them up and they’d do the things to stay competitive and independent. Even though our group could claim victory that Semel quit in June, the board stayed the same, they didn’t ask anyone else to leave. They did reduce some of the overlapping divisions in the company but not enough. Jerry Yang, who I have huge admiration for, I was hoping he would be more decisive and faster moving. And he’s been the opposite, and has been incremental and plodding and not very clear and articulate in charting where the company is going.
Because of that plodding style, he lost the trust of people on Wall Street and let the stock price drop to the level that Microsoft made the offer. They backed themselves into this situation. I thought Jerry Yang could have laid off a lot of people when he took over, outsourced search, and done some exciting things, but they didn’t. Given that Jerry and the board have been bumbling along for the last four years, I don’t have confidence that they can be successful running this company independently or combining their assets with AOL or MySpace. If I had a choice of taking $31 or higher from Microsoft or believing that Jerry will be able to turn the company around and get the stock price back up beyond $31, I think the right thing for shareholders is to get the money now.
So how many shares do you have pledged now for the Microsoft buyout?
Jackson: Since we posted it, we have another 30 pledgers with 100,000 shares. So that brings us to 2.2 million shares. It hasn’t gone up dramatically. I would hope that, if not in this campaign, that in the future, this type of thing with individual shareholders banding together would happen more often. It was reported that Steve Ballmer met with Yahoo’s biggest shareholder, Capital Research, and he was selling the deal. When you think of all the individual shareholders who are out there…if they join together, they could have a group two or three times the size of Capital Research and have the same type of power. With the tools of the Internet, making that happen is more feasible than ever before. People just don’t realize the power that they have. There’s nothing special about me.
A couple months ago, I was on a Yahoo Finance message board for the company Palm, and someone wrote this thread saying, ‘Have you heard about this guy Eric Jackson and his Plan B group and he got Terry Semel fired? We need to do that with Palm, we need to get an Eric Jackson to help us out!’ I thought, there’s nothing special about me. Any of these guys writing on this post could start their own Plan B, start a wiki and make it happen. A lot of people don’t think that way. I would hope that five years from now, more people will think that way and there will be more case studies to give inspiration to people to do it. The more people get engaged and speak out, the healthier our capital markets are.
*****
What do you think? Will social media allow more people like Eric Jackson to make a stink over public companies that are performing badly? Can they really change the slow performance of boards? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Posted by
Unknown
at
4:46 PM
0
comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Corporate Governance, Eric Jackson, Jerry Yang, Microsoft, Shareholder Activism, Steve Ballmer, Terry Semel, Yahoo
Last weekend, the Times ran an interview with Carl Icahn, in which the legendary investor commented on how the credit crisis will affect activist investors. (According to Icahn, 'saber-rattling' won't be enough in this environment.) Today, another similar article appeared in the Journal by Gregory Zuckerman.
In this one, Zuckerman noted "activist angst" and stated that such funds could be "left in the dust" as they can no longer just advocate "pressuring companies to sell out, pay juicy dividends and buy back shares".
As someone who practices activist investing -- albeit as an individual using the Internet, rather than a hedge fund -- I couldn't be happier about these developments. Flip through Ken Squire's 13D update in Barron's every week for the past couple of years and you will find most investors prescribing the Holy Trinity of Mainstream Activism: Get Sold, Pay a Dividend, and Buy back Shares. This is not long-term unlocking of value; this is Activism By Numbers. And, hopefully, a credit tightening will flush these investors with a simplistic approach out of the market.
To be a successful activist in this market, you will have to understand the operations of the company and its industry. You will have to know how to help a company execute a turnaround. You will have to carefully study the composition of the board and management team and the strategy they have developed (or not developed, as the case may be). You will also have to build a coalition of other like-minded and frustrated investors.
The Journal article recognizes this. "Activists with turnaround expertise may be the only ones who thrive in the new hedge-fund world." Dan Loeb at Third Point is mentioned as an example of an activist battling on in this manner. Icahn will continue, of course.
I will continue to push for positive changes at Motorola and Yahoo! Yahoo!'s stock has rebounded substantially today on a positive Bear Stearns' report suggesting its take-out value is $50 per share. Motorola is up with the broader market today and -- interestingly -- UBS mentions it as a likely activist target in the next 12 months.
We will soon see who can perform as an activist in good and bad markets.
___
I found a blog posting over the weekend mentioning Microsoft as an activist target. The author pleads that a significant MSFT shareholder with a "spine" kick-start an activist campaign. He asked why I had not become involved, as well as Capital Research and others.
First off, I'm flattered that he'd suggest I get involved. I'm happy to chat with him or anyone else, if they want to suggest companies in which value could be unlocked.
However, I'd encourage him/her or anyone else to look inside before looking to others for help. You do not need to be an activist hedge fund to run an activist campaign -- although having one support you helps. You need to make your case for change. If it's compelling, others will support you -- why wouldn't they, if it will benefit them as a shareholder. Capital Research and other large institutions are made up of individuals. You just need to find the ones who care about Microsoft or any other company.
I haven't looked in detail at Microsoft, but I would like to launch a blitzkrieg of new activist campaigns in the coming weeks against worthy targets. I would appreciate any suggestions of readers' top picks for companies -- large and small -- who could benefit from some agitated investors wanting to push for some needed changes. Please email or comment your suggestions. Thanks.
Posted by
Unknown
at
4:14 PM
0
comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Capital Research, Carl Icahn, Dan Loeb, Microsoft, Third Point
Posted by
Unknown
at
10:34 AM
0
comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Board, Corporate Governance, Dean Lindroth, Ed Zander, Motorola
From today's Naples News:
By Laura Layden
Originally published — 11:11 p.m., August 6, 2007
Updated — 5:51 a.m., August 7, 2007
Eric Jackson has put out his final call to Motorola.
He has finalized what he calls “Plan B” for the company.
The Naples activist investor sent the plan to the cell phone maker and its independent directors a week ago.
With more than 120 investors rallied behind him, he hopes to “return the company to its rightful leadership position in the communications industry.”
Using only the Internet, Jackson has drummed up support for his plan. Using his blog and YouTube, he ran a similar campaign against Yahoo! that observers say helped oust Terry Semel as chief executive officer a few months ago.
Jackson hasn’t heard back from Motorola yet. A Motorola spokesman couldn’t immediately be reached for comment.
The investors behind Jackson’s plan own 600,000 shares. He owns 180 shares.
“The response has been very positive. I think people are disappointed in the recent performance of Motorola,” said Jackson, 35, a business and management consultant and president and CEO of Jackson Leadership Systems Inc. in Naples.
Most supporters are small investors. Among them is 17-year-old Jordan Wells, who owns five shares of Motorola stock.
“We’ve already seen blogs and grassroots technology shake up the political world. It’s great to see them shaking up the financial world,” Wells wrote in an e-mail to Jackson.
Jackson’s campaign comes after billionaire investor Carl Icahn lost a proxy fight against Motorola and failed to receive enough votes to get elected to the company’s board.
Jackson first developed a draft plan, which he sent to the company in early July. During the past few weeks, he has refined the plan based on suggestions he received from supporters by phone and through his wiki Web page and e-mail.
Here are the demands in the final plan:
Œ Ed Zander must immediately leave as chairman and CEO.
Œ Replace Judy Lewent, Nicolas Negroponte, Samuel Scott III, and Dr. John White on Motorola’s board of directors.
Œ Appoint Edward Lampert to Motorola’s board and others with deep communications experience.
Œ Reduce the size of, and insiders on, the board.
Œ Outline Motorola’s strategy and how it will add exciting new products.
Œ Give Motorola’s culture an inspirational transfusion.
The plan criticizes Zander for not having a clear vision for the company. It asks directors to answer these questions: What has been Ed Zander’s mark on Motorola? He came with a Silicon Valley background, but how has that experience or those past ties translated into tangible results for the company? What has he brought to Motorola in the last 3 1/2 years?
“The fact that there are no obvious answers to these questions screams why a change is needed now,” the plan says.
The plan demands that the board immediately renegotiate Zander’s severance package to ensure that he doesn’t receive $30 million simply for leaving the company.
The plan questions the independence of board directors Lewent, Negroponte, Scott and White because they’ve been on the board so long. It suggests adding Lampert of ESL Investments Inc. to the board because of his strong track record of business experience. He recently purchased stock in the company.
The Motorola board now has three insiders on it: Ed Zander, Greg Brown and Tom Meredith.
At a time when the company has underperformed, the plan suggests that only the CEO serve on the board and criticizes the board for being too large with 13 members.
There seems to be no clear strategy for Motorola, the plan says, and the 18 new models that have reached the market this year have had only lukewarm response.
“In our opinion, none of the models is a game-changing device that will sweep up the consumer or business space,” Jackson says in the plan. “They are incrementalist improvements on past styles. Recent excitement over competitors’ new product launches makes the differences all the more stark.”
Nokia recently announced an “amazing quarter” and its market share is about 38 percent, Jackson said. Motorola has 13 percent of the market, and has slipped to No. 3, behind Nokia and Samsung, he said.
The plan points to “a significant cultural problem.”
“The biggest barrier Motorola faces to righting the ship is not moving some numbers around on the corporate balance sheet; it’s winning back the hearts and minds of its own people,” Jackson said, addressing the board in the plan.
He said “confusion, cynicism and fear appear to have taken root following the recent rounds of layoffs.”
Many supporters of Jackson’s plan are Motorola employees. The support came more quickly this time after his success with Plan B for Internet search giant Yahoo!
Jackson has asked to meet with the Motorola board as soon as possible to discuss the plan.
In the plan, he makes it clear that the investor group doesn’t believe there is a quick fix for Motorola.
“Replacing Ed Zander alone is not the solution; it will require a multipronged effort,” the plan concludes.
If there is enough support from investors, Jackson said he may push Motorola to hold a special meeting to allow shareholders to vote on the plan.
“I would definitely like to meet with the board members and present our views face to face,” he said.
“I think they would be doing their shareholders a service to show they are open to listening to new ideas and open to constructive dialog,” he said.
From this morning's Chicago Daily Herald:
By Anna Marie Kukec
Daily Herald Business Writer
akukec@dailyherald.com
Posted Tuesday, July 31, 2007
A Florida-based consultant credited with helping to oust a chief executive at Yahoo Inc. has been gaining a following in his quest to remove Motorola Inc.'s chief executive.
Eric Jackson, president of Jackson Leadership Systems Inc., a governance consulting firm in Naples, Fla., said Monday that he has 126 people now behind him who collectively own about 600,000 Motorola shares.
He submitted a plan Monday to the company's board of directors seeking the immediate removal of CEO Ed Zander and to enlist other changes to get the beleaguered communications company back on track.
"I am hoping that our plan will be taken seriously by the non-executive members of the board and that they will agree to meet with me to discuss our ideas," said Jackson. "It would look badly on them if they refused. From that dialogue, I hope we'll be able to find some common ground which will be beneficial to all shareholders."
Jackson follows billionaire activist Carl Icahn, who earlier this year failed to win a seat on the Motorola board in his quest to change the company's direction.
Jackson's previous campaign was against former Yahoo CEO Terry Semel, who resigned under fire more than a month ago. Jackson included videos about him on YouTube and a page on Flickr as part of that campaign.
A Motorola spokeswoman Monday declined to comment on Jackson's plan. However, Motorola executives have said that the board has not been looking to replace Zander.
Jackson, who owns about 100 Motorola shares, set up a "pledge" site at the beginning of his campaign three weeks ago at www.youchoose.net/pledge/motorolaplanb .
"If they fail to acknowledge us, we will look to pursue a special shareholder vote perhaps sooner than the annual meeting seeking faster changes," said Jackson.
Posted by
Unknown
at
9:06 AM
1 comments
Labels: Activist Investing, Ed Zander, Eric Jackson, Motorola
Fellow Motorola Shareholders:
Today, I formally submitted our finalized "Plan B" for Motorola to the Non-Executive members of Motorola's Board. Over the last 3 weeks, I have received numerous suggestions from you and others like you who have been frustrated by the Company's performance and want to see a significant change versus the status quo.
These comments have come via our wiki, through private phone conversations, by email, or by comments directly on the blog. I sincerely appreciate all the ideas. Many current Motorola employees used this as an opportunity to speak up with their positive suggestions for change to make this a better Company. Our plan is much stronger and specific as a result of their input.
We now have a formal group of 126 individual investors with about 600,000 shares of Motorola stock owned collectively.
In the past few weeks, I have also spoken to a large majority of representatives from Motorola's largest institutional shareholders. Many didn't want to formally "join" our group in publicly criticizing the company (for different reasons), but they are clearly frustrated and many told me that they were sympathetic with our views. They also told me that they would be (or already recently had been) in touch directly with Motorola to express their views.
The letter below was sent this afternoon to Dean Lindroth, Corporate Vice President and Director of Investor Realtions for Motorola. I asked him to distribute it to the Non-Executive Members of the Board and to arrange, as soon as is possible, for me to meet with or speak by conference call with these Directors. Working with them, it is my hope that we can find a solution that will benefit all Motorola employees, customers, and shareholders.
In the meantime, I ask you to continue to support our group with your new pledges, provide suggestions of key Motorola shareholders to speak with, and provide us with your suggestions and observations. Working together, we can ensure that this company is doing everything it possibly can to build a successful future.
Thanks again for all of your support. Here is a copy of the letter and finalized "Plan B" sent to Motorola today:
July 30, 2007
Dear Motorola Non-Executive Board Members:
As a Motorola shareholder, and leader of 126 individual investors with a combined 600,000 shares in the Company, I’m writing to you to demand you fulfill your fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders by implementing our proposed “Plan B” solution (outlined below) for positive and much-needed change at the 79 year old American institution. Working together, we believe the ideas contained within the plan can quickly and most effectively return the Company to its rightful leadership position in the communications industry.
At the moment, there is little for shareholders and employees to get excited about with Motorola. Since January 2nd, 2004, the month Ed Zander took over as the Chairman and CEO, through last Friday’s trading, Motorola has returned 23% to its shareholders. Nokia, the #1 mobile handset maker in the world, has returned 68% over the time period. The S&P 500 has returned 33%. Motorola’s shareholders would have enjoyed a 3x return, if they had put their money in Nokia – instead of Motorola – when Ed Zander started. We don’t believe this past performance and the currently articulated strategy for a turnaround, as well as the more recent announcements in the days since the draft version of this “Plan B” first circulated on the Internet, are sufficient or acceptable. This company has a leadership and a mobile product problem which needs to be corrected today – not in 6 months from now, after it falls further behind its competitors.
Over the past 3 weeks, I’ve had the opportunity to communicate with most of Motorola’s largest shareholders, as well as several current and former Motorola employees. Well over 95% of those I’ve contacted want change and are frustrated by the perceived slow response by the Senior Leadership Team (SLT) and board to the problems facing the company. Most of these shareholders do not want to sell their shares – although seeing the stock price hit a new 52-week low is testing their patience and resolve. They also don’t want to passively wait for the current SLT to deliver on promises for change. Frankly, the last year of broken promises from the SLT doesn’t provide shareholders with much confidence any longer.
As a result, my group has banded together to demand that you act immediately in implementing several much-needed changes for the Company. Other institutional shareholders who do not wish to publicly join our group are nevertheless frustrated with the performance of the Company and are seeking changes. Several have confirmed that they are sympathetic with our views but do not wish to formally “join” our group. However, I will let them speak to you directly to express their views. I know that several have already been in touch with you in these past few weeks. Our group is working towards benefiting all Motorola’s shareholders – whether or not they are formal members of our group.
After the May annual meeting, at which several shareholders expressed their disappointment and asked for change, Motorola and Mr. Zander promised exciting new handset models in the coming weeks which would play a key role in the turnaround for Motorola’s Mobile Devices Business (MDB) and, thus, Motorola itself in the remainder of the calendar year. These models have now been released – to a tepid response from customers and Wall Street[1]. Now, in the latest quarterly results, we have been told not to expect MDB to be profitable this year and the turnaround to take much longer. Mr. Zander has assured reporters following the earnings call that he’s “working really hard.”[2] This is not acceptable.
We demand that the board to undertake aggressive changes at Motorola.
Instead of only presenting the problems facing the Company (which are numerous), our investor group wants to work with you to be part of the solution which will deliver extraordinary value to Motorola shareholders and make it a better company for its employees and customers. Below, we present the finalized version of our “Plan B” to put Motorola on a path back to its rightful place as the worldwide leader in communications. Over the past 3 weeks, we have received many suggestions and edits from supporters through our wiki, by phone, and through emails/comments which have been incorporated into this final version.
1. Ed Zander Must Immediately Leave as Chairman and CEO:
This January marks the 4 year anniversary of Mr. Zander’s hiring. Nokia and the S&P 500 have exceeded Motorola’s shareholder returns by 196% and 43% respectively over that time period. According to recent quarterly data, Motorola will drop from the #2 to the #3 position in worldwide handset sales – for the first time ever.[3] The results from the past year have been under-whelming, as the company sank to negative margins. The Q2 numbers were well-below previous expectations.[4]
We call on you to each honestly answer the following question: What has been Ed Zander’s mark on Motorola? He came with a Silicon Valley background, but how has that experience or those past ties translated into tangible results for the Company? What has he brought to Motorola that is really unique in the last 3½ years? The fact that there are no obvious answers to these questions screams why a change is needed now.
You can agree or disagree with Terry Semel’s vision for Yahoo!, but he had a vision. There is no discernible vision or articulated strategy for Motorola by Mr. Zander. At the May 31st, 2007, Lehman Brothers Worldwide Wireless & Wireline Conference[5], Mr. Zander stated: “We have a strategy: Seamless Mobility.” This concept is repeated often on the corporate website – even recently by board members[6] – and in letters to shareholders. What does it mean? How does it suggest Motorola will better compete with its rivals in its Mobile, Networks, and Connected Home divisions? If shareholders cannot figure this out, can Motorola’s employees? Many have contacted me in the past few weeks confirming they cannot. A concept (and an abstract one at that) is not a strategy.
When Mr. Zander arrived at Motorola in January 2004, he was blessed with the good fortune of the success of RAZR developed under the direction of his predecessor. He did well at marketing this hit product and was able to take credit for its success, but he did not address the underlying issues at the company around software platforms in MDB and proceeded to make a number of disastrous strategic missteps for the Company. As RAZR showed its popularity, he decided to forgo millions in profits for the Company by slashing prices, in hopes of grabbing market share. COO Greg Brown proudly crowed on the last disappointing earnings call that the Company had just shipped its 100 millionth RAZR. We would ask each of you and Mr. Brown: at what price? Now that RAZR’s run is over – and with Motorola’s share evaporating – Mr. Zander has now pronounced that seeking market share is bad and that the Company instead will go after profits. Why is what was right then, wrong now, and vice-versa?
It was only when troubles became obvious to all, at the end of RAZR's run, when Mr. Zander began to rationalize costs and accelerate plans for a next-generation of phones. It wasn’t Mr. Zander’s fault alone (Greg Brown also deserves blame, as do other members of the SLT and the MDB divisional leadership), but the buck stops with him. This should have been done after the initial release of the RAZR to prepare for the next-generation phone in the GSM space, where Motorola has traditionally made most of its profits. Instead, a huge focus and amount of resources were poured into the development of the MotoQ smartphone, as it was thought that this would be the next-generation phone consumers would want. The smartphone idea might have been correct, but the execution was poor and the initial CDMA target market small; the phone flopped. The subsequent GSM offering of the MotoQ came late behind other smartphones with equivalent technology, such as the Blackjack from Samsung.
Now, the Company’s focus must be on turnaround.
Mr. Zander does not have a track record of success in turnarounds. He has ridden the wave of upward growth in his past positions. He left Sun in 2002, just as it was in greatest need of a turnaround. It’s time to bring in someone who does have a turnaround track record.
We are also deeply concerned with the reports which surfaced in an April Wall Street Journal article[7] that Mr. Zander allegedly said: “I love my job. I hate my customers” in response to a question about why Motorola’s carrier customers were discounting the prices of Motorola’s phones. He later apparently suggested that, one day, he was going to use that line as the title for his memoirs. Motorola tried to defuse this story leading up to the May 7th annual meeting, by stating the company and Mr. Zander care about their customers. Everyone makes mistakes, but, in our opinion, this episode suggests arrogance or at least poor judgment that (1) Mr. Zander would actually say this and (2) he would be contemplating possible titles for his memoirs. According to research done by Dartmouth Tuck Professor Sydney Finkelstein (who is also a colleague), corporate and CEO arrogance is a critical reason “why smart executives fail”[8]. We believe that, although not the sole reason, this poor judgment or arrogance, combined with failing to articulate a strategy, failing to prepare the organization for the end of the RAZR wave, and – most importantly – the under-performance of the stock compared to its rivals are the main reasons why Motorola shareholders would benefit from new leadership at the top.
A final note on this first point: we call on you to immediately renegotiate Mr. Zander's severance package to ensure that he does not receive $30 million simply for leaving the company in its current state of disrepair after these ill-fated last 3.5 years. He has already been highly compensated for under-performing Nokia and the S&P. A $30 million severance package would be an insult to all Motorola shareholders and must be eliminated as a measure of good faith that Motorola's employees and shareholders will not pay the price long after Mr. Zander's tenure has ended.
2. Replace Judy Lewent, Nicolas Negroponte, Samuel Scott III, and Dr. John White on the Motorola Board of Directors:
All Motorola shareholders had a sense of déjà vu watching what happened with RAZR, as Motorola has lived the story before of riding the wave of a hot product without sufficient heed to where the industry is moving to. Ten years ago, it was with StarTAC: the “iconic” hit phone, which was analog-based. All the signs pointed to the industry moving to digital. In fact, as Motorola licensed its digital technology to its competitors like Nokia at the time, the Company could see first-hand through quarterly royalty payments just how quickly this shift to digital was happening in the market. However, the Company did not act on the data in front of it and its plans for digital phones were delayed, so that additional resources could “feed the beast” of StarTAC. The company almost drove off the precipice as a result. Fortunately, for its customers, employees, and shareholders, it pulled itself back from the brink. If we substituted the words ‘RAZR’ for ‘StarTAC’ and ‘3G’ for ‘digital,’ we would effectively be retelling the StarTAC episode as exactly what we’ve just lived through with RAZR. Why have Motorola’s shareholders been condemned to have unlearned Company lessons of the past revisited on them?
Chris Galvin, the former CEO and grandson of Motorola’s founder, is no longer around. However, 4 of Motorola’s current board of 13 were around. Judy Lewent has served on the board since 1995. Nicolas Negroponte has been on the board since 1996. Dr. John White has been on the board since 1995. And Presiding Director Samuel Scott III has been on the board for almost 15 years.
In the wake of Sarbanes-Oxley, a lot of attention has rightly been paid to the issue of board “independence.” We agree that it is a good thing to have directors who are sufficiently vigilant and will ask hard questions of management. Yet, we question how “independent” you can be when you’ve served on a board for over a decade? Meg Whitman, CEO of eBay, famously said that no CEO should stay in the same job for 10 years or they risk becoming stale in the saddle.[9] We agree and think this same benchmark should apply to all corporate directors for the sake of fresh eyes and energetic vigilance.
One argument a defender of keeping a director on the same board for over a decade could make is that: it is critical for retaining some “institutional memory” in board discussions. Presumably, these longer-serving directors could remind their shorter-tenured brethren about organizational mistakes made in the past that shouldn’t be repeated – such as StarTAC. We thank Ms. Lewent, Mr. Negroponte, Dr. White, and Mr. Scott for their extensive years of service, but Motorola needs new independent directors with strong business and communications experience. We call on these 4 individuals to drop their directorships with the Company immediately.
3. Appoint Edward Lampert to the Motorola Board and Others with Deep Communications Experience:
As mentioned above, the Motorola board has – in the past – chosen to appoint directors with an abundance of experience outside Motorola’s core communications markets. While we don’t advocate a board only consisting of industry veterans, we believe a solid majority of directors should be experienced within the markets in which Motorola directly competes, rather than – for example – from the pharmaceutical, consumer packaged goods, agricultural, and academic worlds. Therefore, we suggest replacements for the 4 people named above reflect this. New Motorola director David Dorman who is ex-AT&T certainly has communications experience.
Strong business experience and a track record of success are also important criteria for a director. So is the psychological importance of owning a meaningful amount of stock in the company (which a director has directly purchased, as opposed to stock ownership through stock grants or stock options received as partial compensation for board service). We note that 10 out of 13 of the current Motorola directors own less than 50,000 shares, with 4 directors owning less than 5,000 shares (and we suspect that most of these holdings came through received stock grants or exercised stock options, rather than digging into their own pockets to purchase stock). In our opinion, that is simply not enough “skin in the game” for a corporate director of a Fortune 50 company.
One candidate that we believe fits the bill for a strong track record of business experience, as well as Motorola stock ownership, is Edward Lampert of ESL Investments Inc. His credentials are impeccable. Mr. Lampert also disclosed he is now a holder of Motorola stock following the May annual meeting[10]. We suggest that Motorola make a spot available for him immediately at the board of directors’ table.
4. Reduce the Size of and Insiders on the Board:
Regrettably, the board now has 3 insiders on it: Ed Zander, Greg Brown, and Tom Meredith. Mr. Meredith was initially an independent outsider, but is now clearly an insider - working closely with Zander (as any CFO must with a CEO). In our view, at a time when the current management team has under-delivered to shareholders, only the CEO needs to serve on this board - defending the status quo moves of management. The rest of the board should be outsiders with truly fresh perspectives pushing management. The board needs to reduce this imbalance immediately.
Adding Greg Brown to the board at this time, we believe, sends the message to shareholders that this board is committed to more of the same - not holding management's feet to the fire. Mr. Scott III, Motorola’s Presiding Director, defended naming Brown to the board by saying: “Greg will provide invaluable perspectives to the board on the key opportunities and challenges of our global business.”[11] At any board meeting, it is possible to invite any member of the management team to sit in and present on key strategic issues. You simply don’t need to name someone a director to tap into those perspectives.
Additionally, this board (now at 13 people) is too large. Research has found that, when boards get larger, there is less discussion and debate.[12] The larger group seems to inhibit more active discussion and "devil's advocacy." Instead, more "rubber stamping" of decisions put forward by the Chair/CEO/Presiding Director occurs. No one would say Motorola’s board needs more rubber stamping.
One final observation on this point: at the moment, Nokia has 11 directors, and Microsoft has 10 directors. Why does Motorola need 13? We believe this board should have 10 or fewer members.
5. Outline Motorola’s Strategy and How You Will Add Exciting New Products:
In the May Lehman Brothers speech, Mr. Zander said a company’s strategy shouldn’t change year to year, but its tactics should. We couldn’t agree more. However, the stated Company strategy is simply “Seamless Mobility.” A recent analyst who has analyzed the clarity of Mr. Zander’s letters to shareholders for the last few years, according to the Wall Street Journal, called them “Bafflegab.”[13] A notable quotation from the 2005 Motorola annual report letter cited is: “Motorola's going to own Seamless Mobility, where today's hottest technology is converging -- where the Mobile Me lives -- where mobile broadband means everything everywhere and anything anywhere." A new clichéd term Mr. Zander is fond of using – and we suspect he’s used it more than a few times in presentations to you – is “profit pools” (as in “we’ve got to find the profit pools”). Three and a half years into his tenure, the company and its shareholders desperately need to better understand the strategy for turning things around.
The recent attack which Motorola directed at Mr. Icahn leading up to the annual meeting was – in our opinion – a smoke-screen. By asking shareholders to focus on the number of directorships currently held by Mr. Icahn, Motorola’s leadership avoided having to better explain its own strategy for the company.
A long-term vision and strategy is not cost containments and site rationalizations alone. Controlling costs is obviously critical when your major division is seeing sales recede as much as they have in the last year (and some of our supporters suggest Motorola could benefit from further axing generous travel policies where multiple Motorolans fly to the same meetings and any flight over 5 hours qualifies you to fly business class). Yet, no company shrank itself to greatness. The simple truth is that customers do not like the current line-up of phones and there needs to be a better strategy for more compelling phones that will raise revenue.
Getting 18 new models out to market this year to lukewarm response doesn’t fix that problem. The RAZR2 is 10x as fast as the RAZR and has an armload of new features, but potential customers don’t seem to care. In our opinion, none of the models is a game-changing device that will sweep up the consumer or business space. They are incrementalist improvements on past styles. Recent excitement over competitors’ new product launches makes the differences all the more stark. So, what must the new strategy speak to? Next-generation designs.
When you first saw the Chrysler 300C, you turned your head; and you have designer Ralph Gilles to thank for it. The RAZR made this initial impact, and the beloved late Geoffrey Frost (former Motorola Marketing head) played a key role in this. Yet, RAZR2, KRZR, ROKR, RIZR, and the Q9 now appear to be so yesterday.
Management is fond of talking about finally developing Linux/Java platforms to make richer software experiences, and better competing with Nokia and others in certain tiers of the market in which Motorola doesn’t play. Yet, I was recently told by one Motorola employee that the Company’s Linux/Java platform wouldn’t be available until 2009 at the earliest, in part due to relocating work on this from Urbana-Champaign to Beijing. And only recently did Motorola hire a Chief Architect for its software platform, after this role remained vacant for too long. Small wonder that no one was able to speak with accountability on how the software platform was to progress across the Company.
But this focus on the software platform – important as it is – masks the fact that customers care little about Linux/Java; they want to have a user experience which allows them, once again, to fall in love with Motorola devices. The user interface and product design “know how” for this is already in house, as Motorola has an extensive Labs group. However, the processes and structures need to be put in place to get them to market. And product marketing people need to be given authority to champion these new products. The status quo of operations is not bringing them out.
The RAZR phone was developed by a small, cross-functional group outside Motorola’s standard processes. Since Mr. Zander has joined Motorola, the bureaucracy appears to have grown – not decreased – according to some Motorola employees I’ve been in touch with. More time should not be spent on generating paperwork than actually developing the product.
Corporate strategy also has to be more than just Mobile Devices strategy. With so much attention being paid to problems in Mobile Devices, what strategic focus and resources are being applied to the other businesses? What Motorola investors want to know is what they can expect from the Networks and Connected Home businesses as part of their MOT investment in years to come. What was the rationale for keeping them and jettisoning the Semiconductor business a few years ago? How will Connected Home effectively compete in the years ahead? Where is Government/Public Safety going? Are we prepared for 4G?
Several of our supporters have asked simply why these 3 businesses need to be knitted together at all. The Networks and Connected Home businesses (with $13 billion and $5 billion of annual sales respectively) have been independently successful with attractive margins. As there appears to be little knowledge-sharing between these groups, should they be broken up to extract more value for shareholders. If not, why not?
The process by which Motorola followed for getting out of the semiconductor business demonstrates poor portfolio management and long-term planning on the part of those in Corporate responsible for these choices. Here’s a quick review of what happened. The decision to spin-off the Semiconductor business was announced in October 2003[14]. The IPO came in July 2004, delivering $1.5 billion to Motorola shareholders[15]. The decision was defended as a way for the company to “focus” on its core businesses and increase shareholder value through the spin-out. Yet, Motorola continued to work with Freescale (the newly named spun-out entity), as if it was a business it owned within the Motorola family, sole-sourcing chips for many of its phones. Part of the recent downturn in MDB is due to the fact that Motorola has been producing phones at a cost disadvantage, because it hasn’t multi-sourced silicon from other vendors two years after the Freescale IPO. This risk should have been identified and baked into the corporate strategy by head office well in advance.
6. Give Motorola’s Culture an Inspirational Transfusion:
If you are not aware that this Company has a significant cultural problem at the moment, then you have not sat down to chat with some of its greatest employees. The biggest barrier Motorola faces to righting the ship is not moving some numbers around on the corporate Balance Sheet; it’s winning back the hearts and minds of its own people. As an investor, I was aghast at how much of a disconnect appears to exist between this Company’s leadership and the people they purportedly lead.
Confusion, cynicism, and fear appear to have taken root following the recent rounds of layoffs. At the same time, the employees who drive this company forward feel betrayed by a SLT. At times, they feel blamed by the SLT. This fear and mistrust obviously discourage innovation. Several employees complain about a death by 1000 committees mentality strangling product innovation.
At its core, Motorola is still an engineering company. This must evolve. Product marketing needs to be given more authority to ensure Motorola’s customers get the products they want – not the features only a few engineers want.
How do you inject some life and hope into this culture? Removing Ed Zander will not change the culture overnight, but it is a necessary step. Hiring a capable successor is equally, if not more, important. Look at HP under Mark Hurd versus Carly Fiorina. The differences in the Company’s culture are palpable when you talk to people there today. No HP director would say they should have waited longer before letting Ms. Fiorina go. Just the opposite. The same is true here at this time, which is why Mr. Zander must go now.
I request to meet with you at your earliest possible convenience to discuss our plan and the merits of implementing it. We must move past the mistakes of the past and take the steps now to make a better Motorola.
Let me be clear: our investor group doesn’t believe there is a quick fix for Motorola. Replacing Ed Zander alone is not the solution; it will require a multi-pronged effort. In our view, investors, working with the board and the new SLT, need to take the long-view and dig in for some difficult work ahead. The changes must start now though. Our group is made up of long-term investors in the company who are committed to seeing it return to its rightful place of industry leadership. A stronger Motorola is good for its shareholders, customers, and employees.
The time is now. This is a great company that can be and will be again.
Sincerely yours,
Eric M. Jackson, Ph.D.
[1] http://www.forbes.com/2007/07/03/zander-motorola-razr-pf-ii-in_jl_0703soapbox_inl.html?partner=yahootix
[2] http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aJTWQGhpoCxo&refer=home
[3] http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/20070719/motorola-samsung-shipments.htm
[4] http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/20/business/20motorola.html
[5] http://cc.talkpoint.com/LEHM002/053007a_jw/default.asp?entity=Motorola
[6] http://money.cnn.com/news/newsfeeds/articles/prnewswire/AQW19625072007-1.htm
[7] http://online.wsj.com/article/SB117798906186487805-search.html?KEYWORDS=zander&COLLECTION=wsjie/6month
[8] http://www.whysmartexecutivesfail.com/
[9] http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2006/11/19/BUGPUMEPAG1.DTL&type=business
[10] http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601103&refer=us&sid=ai5qQcW6SJTI
[11] http://money.cnn.com/news/newsfeeds/articles/prnewswire/AQW19625072007-1.htm
[12] http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0001-4273(199210)35%3A4%3C766%3AIASCPO%3E2.0.CO%3B2-J
[13] http://online.wsj.com/article/SB117866044480696317-search.html?KEYWORDS=motorola+zander&COLLECTION=wsjie/6month
[14] http://news.com.com/2100-1006_3-5086763.html
[15] http://www.marketwatch.com/News/Story/Story.aspx?guid=%7BD21FF9BE-6F22-4F77-A6D8-A2FBCF53F90F%7D&dist=rss&siteid=mktw